Raw 1923-D Peace $1---Care to guess the grade?

lablover

I'm thinking about submitting these two 1923-D Peace $1. Your input on the possible grade and if it's worthwhile to even submit would be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance.

BigD5

This is one series where I'm miserable at grading. Don't mind admitting it either. I'd say the top coin is au/58, and the bottom piece is ms/62.

Of course, that's from the scan, and probably doesn't mean diddly.

Let us know how they come back if you decide to send 'em in.

grip

They both look to have quite a few marks/scratches,I wouldn't send them in if they were mine.Al

itsnotjustme

AU55
MS62

I'm no expert on Peace dollars. I find detecting early wear very tough, but I do think the top coin shows wear. I would not submit the first, and might the second.

FrattLaw

I don't see wear on either one and would bet they would both go MS62/63. And I love the toned one.

It's up to you as for spending the money for slabbing them.

Michael

lablover

BigD5, grip, itsnotjustme, FrattLaw,

Thanks to each of you for the input. Neither coin is circulated so I may just submit and see what happens.