It would depend on how long that '57 die lasted in 1858. 500 sounds like a small number until you start looking for the clashes of '57, then it sounds huge.
There are a couple 1858 over 7's, the S1 and the S7. The pictures below are from 2 MS63 examples.
The S1 (left picture) is scarce as a very early die state coin, relatively common in later die states. Alot of these coins get sold as overdates when only the broken wing can be seen. These shouldn't command a premium. 54 early die state coins have been reported to the Fly In club to date, 12 in MS condition. The auction appearance would suggest it is a bit more common than this.
The right picture is from the S7. It is much rarer, 12 reported to date, 3 in MS condition. The S7 also show repunching of the 1.
Bowers notes that each "1858" die struck on average 106,957 coins. Each of the 2 1858/7 dies may have struck that many. This compares to 24,600,000 large and small letter 1858's.
Gone but not forgotten: IGWT, Speedy, Bear, BigE, HokieFore, John Burns, Russ, TahoeDale, Dahlonega, Astrorat, Stewart Blay, Oldhoopster, Ricko, Big Moose, Cardinal, CoinsAreFun.
Comments
It would depend on how long that '57 die lasted in 1858.
500 sounds like a small number until you start looking for the clashes of '57, then it sounds huge.
My pic doesn't show it too well but it is there.
The 7 doesn't show on these like on an 8/7 buff.
Now look outside the top loop of the second 8 at about 1-2 o clock! see it??? then look at mine! Link to a HIGH grade one.
The S1 (left picture) is scarce as a very early die state coin, relatively common in later die states. Alot of these coins get sold as overdates when only the broken wing can be seen. These shouldn't command a premium. 54 early die state coins have been reported to the Fly In club to date, 12 in MS condition. The auction appearance would suggest it is a bit more common than this.
The right picture is from the S7. It is much rarer, 12 reported to date, 3 in MS condition. The S7 also show repunching of the 1.
Bowers notes that each "1858" die struck on average 106,957 coins. Each of the 2 1858/7 dies may have struck that many. This compares to 24,600,000 large and small letter 1858's.
chris