Results are in on the three rainbow Morgans I picked up at PNNA.

Russ

When I first got these, I posted the images and a lively discussion ensued about what they would grade. So, off to NGC they went, with a promise that I'd update when I had the results - which took less than a month for economy, BTW.

Click here for the original discussion.

1885-O #1, MS64:


1885-O #2, MS64:


And, the one that generated the most heated grading debate:

1887, MS63:


Now, I have a question about the toning itself. I think it's endroll? Is that correct?

Russ, NCNE

Tassa

Looks like endroll toning to me.

Dog97

I'd say endrollers except for the 87 which appears to have some textile pattern from a bag around M in UNIM. I see the 87 is MS after all.

K6AZ

Wow, I am surprised by the 87, which I believe was the coin we had the 'lively' discussion on. It just may be a coin that when imaged exaggerates the contact marks. By the way, mine are back, the slip was in the PO Box. I'll be picking them up on Monday.

The 87 does appear to be bag toned. Notice the lines aren't straight, but curved.

fivecents

The pair of 1885-o s' look like they came from different ends of the same roll.

stman

87 AU