Maine Rare coins is crazy

MacCoin

I was at a coin show today the pcgs dealer there was the stupidest or laziest manybe both guy I have ever seen. I had run out of quarter 2x2 and put my xf/au Barber quarter in a used 2x2. it had the word damage on it. I ask the pcgs dealer to grade it and he said it won't grade because it was damaged. I ask where is the damage. he said it had been cleaned. that didn't sound right to me it have the nice dark toning of a older coin. he said I should have looked at the 2x2 before I bought it. it state it was damaged. he also said my other coins wasn't worth submitting because they where not mint state.
a type I 1917 xf/au SLQ and a vf 1921 peace dollar. I kind of think I sould be the judge of that not him. these are coins I already had.
the new ones I got today are a bu 1909 V nickel and a bu 1924 slq. the quarter is blast white and looks nice. the nickel has the nice dark tone.

airplanenut

Look at the coin and not the holder? What kind of collector are you???

cointagious

<< <i>he also said my other coins wasn't worth submitting because they where not mint state. >>




many, many long time dealers do not believe in slabbing circ material, even key dates. except for the better dates, i tend to agree with them. just a waste of $$$.

MacCoin

you know its my money and I think I want to waste it on a pcgs slab even if its not MS

TAP444

I agree with Maccoin, it's your money spend it any way you want
I do the same with mine
Tim

ElectricEye

MAC ~ I have a common circ 64 Kennedy w/rainbow toning at PCGS now (one of the first coins given to me around 1967) ~ I could care less what is it worth in dollars