1913 TYPE 1 BUFFALO MS63/64 NICE TONING or enhanced?????

tsacch

http://cgi1.ebay.com/aw-cgi/eBayISAPI.dll?MakeTrack&item=30163888511913 TYPE 1 BUFFALO MS63/64 NICE TONING!

ok........i need help on this one.............nice coin if it were in a slab, how much is it worth? and is it real toning.......whats the sheets and audience say?

Thanks,

T

Russ

Correct link to auction.

Russ, NCNE

GaCoinGuy

Toning looks real to me, but I aint no expert.......I like that coin.

Tonekiller

It is a good looking at around a 62 to 63. Unfortunately I feel that is environmental damage on the reverse and a spot on the obverse. This seller is good and would correct any issue if the services did not slab the coin. I also agree with GSAGUY that he is also a snot nose…….and a board member.

TBT

jbsteven

tsacch

I believe the toning to be real. The person I bought it from knows his stuff and I trust his word. All of my coins have a 5 day return if you are not 100% satisfied. If you send it in and it gets BBed then just send it back for a 100% refund. good enough guarantee?

The colors are a little nicer in person and I kinda disagree with TBT on the enviromental damage.

heck I would even end the auction for the opening price for you as being a board member.

TBT

I believe I am snot nose #2 and you are snot nose #1

sinin1

This is probably showing my ignorance, but


how can you tell the difference between a MS and a matte proof for this year/type?

braddick

I trust the coin because I 100% TRUST the Seller.

If I doubt the coin I then check out the Seller. In this case, the Seller says the coin is real, and that is absolutely good enough for me.

tsacch

It was not a seller trust issue, its a learning issue for me. I am concerned about the central rear spot as well TBT. I may get it and see what anacs says.....or pcgs for that matter.

His http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&category=11942&item=3016028846 has me wondering though.....why hold that nice coin with your fingers for the photo.... and regarding ms62, i am really not versed in that series, so i am assuming certral strike weakness to be normal/acceptable...and the weakness of the rev wreath.

BNE

It looks real, and mighty attractive. It is not overpriced, IMHO. If I didn't already have a nice example in my toned Buff set, it might well be gone by now -- but I am not looking to slab, so I am less sensitive to environmental conditions that might body-bag it. Buy what you like!

jom

Here's a suggestion: Don't bother. This is a relatively common date and you can even find nicely toned ones in slabs. This coin however doesn't look too bad. I don't see an damage and it is clearly MS. What grade? Who knows...depends on the luster. Strike is fine.

But, again, I suggest to keep looking. Plenty around...but if you like it go for it.

jom

jbsteven

tsaach:

To get the correct lighting it is necessary to hold the coin by the edges to tilt it just right for the photo.

tsacch

cool, well i missed the nickle, if the buyer backs out, let me know.

t

jbsteven

tom:

will do, sorry