If you think Hall and PCGS are wrong, check this thread . . .

DMWJR

Now this a productive thread, by the man himself.

Roosie Collector's What do you think? by David Hall

wondercoin

I am glad DH opened up the discussion and I am hopeful he considers limiting the designation to the bottom bands (just like Franklins are designated using only the bottom bell lines). I went into a little more detail in the thread and I noticed the #1 ALL-TIME PCGS Roosie set collector (Reistrycoin) and the #1 ALL-TIME NGC Roosie set collector (onlyRoosies) also supports use of the bottom bands only to determine the designation. Wondercoin

DMWJR

Mitch for what it's worth, I have the #2 46-64 and the #2 65-present mint state sets, I am fully behind "Bands" and not "Torch." I'm going to e-mail Danny and see if he will chime in.

merz2

Mitch
I agree with you about the bands.