Proof Buffalos

dan1ecu

Does anyone have any advice regarding what to look for in a proof Buffalo nickel? There are two types - matte and satin, correct? Which do you like better and why? Are there any areas where the strike is generally weak?

Thanks,

Dan

coinguy1

Hi Dan,

There are actually three types of Proof Buffalo nickels:

1) Matte proofs, struck from 1913 through 1916 (some claim there are also proof 1917's, but none have been unquestionably verified, to my knowledge).

2) Brilliant proofs struck in 1936 and 1937.

3) Satin proofs struck in 1936. 1936's were struck/produced in both "Satin" or Type1 finish and "brilliant", or type 2 finish.

There are also some extremely rare experimental 1927 "Satin" proofs which many people are unaware of.

Strike should not be an issue/problem with any of these. Generally, the brilliant proof 1936 and 1937 specimens are more popular because they are flashier looking and prettier.

Let me know if I can provide some additional information for you.

dan1ecu

Thanks, Mark –

That’s interesting about the 1927 experimental piece.

Dan

WWW

Now this is the kind of numismatic knowledge we can all appreciate. Even if we don't currently collect proof Buffalo nickels,
to see someone take the time to reply to this post in such a succinct manner is admirable. I am beginning to suspect
that coinguy1 is, among other things, a genuinely nice guy.

coinguy1

WWW - you're crazy! But thank you, sincerely.

Dan - personally, I think that some of the lightly toned (they often turn to colors of yellow, ice-blue and lilac, among other shades) brilliant proof 1936 and 1937 Buffalo nickels are among the prettiest proof type coins to be found.

CarlWohlforth

I think so too!! In fact an ice blue brilliant proof Buffalo is what I chose from my type set for my icon.

<<<<<

coinguy1

Here is a rainbow-toned PCGS PR68 we sold last year that I was in love with. They do NOT all look this good - trust me!

CarlWohlforth

Thanks Mark! That has to be one of my favorite Buffaloes in the whole world! I'm sure many would agree with that.

Monstavet

I just added that Buff to my collection - of coin pics...what a beauty! It almost looks like a cartoon!