What would you grade this Morgan as????

AtcBob · March 9, 2003 8:52PM

Hey all, good morning!

What would this Morgan grade? It's a 1888P???

Just for fun...

Bob

HoosierDaddy · March 9, 2003 8:59PM

Need a better picture to determine if the fields are PL, otherwise, I would call it a MS64, almost a 65. The rim dings, the cheek chatter, the crease on the bottom of the neck and the baggie marks above the eagle head are a bit of a bummer. The strike is groovy, and the 64+ may upgrade if we had a bit clearer shot of the reverse, but then again, what do I know right? :-)

AtcBob · March 9, 2003 9:01PM

Okaie-dokie...lemme see if I can get a better shot...

Bob

AtcBob · March 9, 2003 9:08PM

Here is a better shot of the reverse

Bob

AtcBob · March 9, 2003 9:09PM

Dang wrong pic....

AtcBob · March 9, 2003 9:09PM

AtcBob · March 9, 2003 9:10PM

Here is the NEW Pic...

HoosierDaddy · March 9, 2003 9:18PM

Thanks for the shot Bob,
I still cannot decide if it will go a PL or not - the cameo is not too obvious, but the fields look to be somewhat proof-like. Sadly, the new angle and less glare on the second shot points out the 2 bag marks above the eagle, along with the dings a spit past 12, and at 1, and at 2, another bag mark on the rim at 9, and the breast feathers look a little weak. Still a 64

NOTE: This is just my opinion, and probably a little harsh at that. I have a tendancy to grade out Morgan's a little harder than some. Take it with a grain of salt and a shot of scotch!

Thanks for posting it!