Guess the Grade on this toned Morgan? (answer posted)

DanC

Just for giggles... Here is a new acquisition. 1883-O Morgan. It is slabbed. I've still got a lot to learn about grading Morgans. I'd appreciate your opinions as to grade. I'll post the answer later. Thanks!

prooflike

MS62-63

fantasiize

My guess would be MS63+ (MS65 rev and a MS63+ obv).

Dog97

MS63. I can't give you a 64 because of those digs @ E*P. I wouldn't surprise me if it was in a 64 holder though.

FatMan

I don't think PCGS would give a higher grade than MS63. If the toning is hiding some hits, could go MS62.

Could go MS64 across the street. There, I think I've covered myself.

stman

I think they should say whose holder it's in on these. Not that it makes a difference.

So just for "giggles" I feel it's 63.... but think it's slabbed 64

Dog97

stman you can't see who's holder it's in? Open your eyes!

Russ

Since I've seen the coin, and already told Dan what I thought it should grade, I'm liking these guesses.

Russ, NCNE

DanC

You guys are definitely good.

stman

Glad to see the grade is within reason.