Anyone else grade this beauty AU?

danglen

I was reading this sellers feedback and here is his latest NEG. In responding to it he asks you to look at the coin. I did but I think he obviously has his images messed up

driverbrohs(877) Jan-28-03 17:03:55 PST 802832880 S
Complaint : I will get retaliatory negative but honestly-MAJOR OVER-GRADER and no recourse!
Response by delaney91101 - Doesn't honor bid, finally does cause of Ebay pressure, look at pic-nice AU

Linky to AU Morgan

clevegreg

Please.................... Almost Ungradeable is the only AU thing that I can see on this coin


Greg

Jamericon

To me looks at the most AU and at the least XF. Does appear to have light hairlines.

Steve27

The obverse appears to be XF at best, and there's no pic of the reverse. Why would anyone even bid on this?

dorkkarl

obv only (?) looks reasonably close to au.

K S

au58

No the coin is not AU. No it is not choice. It is cleaned, and a net EF40 at best.
But something is amiss here. If you can believe the feedback, the buyer apparently realized that he screwed up and didn't plan to honor his bid until the seller filed a NPB alert.
Why do some people think that they can buy $1000 coins for $300.
The buyer paid solid EF money for an unappealing EF coin.