Submission Results--Mixed Feelings

fcloud

I used some of these for learning experience, as they were all free. I have seen early halves with the clasp engraved with a letter in PCGS holders, so I thought it was worth a shot. I was hoping for an AU. The 1883 Nickel I have had in my collection for over 20 years, I didn't see any signs of cleaning--oh well. The 1936 dime was upgraded from an ANACS MS64FB--I was hoping to retain the grade, so that was a bonus. The 1929, I must have been sleeping when I looked at that coin was expecting around a 64FB. The 42-P Type two--I don't know what I missed--I expeted a 66, and another bonus the 3-leg, I was expecting a f-15. The 42/1 I was also expecting a f-15. It looks like I may be to easy on the BU/Proof stuff, and not tough enough on the circ stuff.


1 600702XX 1883 5C No CENTS Cleaning
2 600702XX 1929 10C AU55
3 600702XX 1936 10C MS65FB
4 600702XX 1809 50C Damage
1 300256XX 1942-P 5C Type 2 PR64
2 300256XX 1937-D 5C 3 Legs VF30
3 300256XX 1942/1 10C VF25
4 300256XX 1954-S 1C MS65RD

Placid

No bad for the free ones. I think they let the janitor grade those

fcloud

All that and it only took four weeks.

It's odd though, I send them in about ten days apart and they graded them on the same day.

FrattLaw

Are you selling the 42-P Type II proof? I'm interested if you are, please PM with a price.

Thanks
Michael

darktone

fcloud, looks like you had some nice surprises and some not so nice. mike