Home› PSA Set Registry Forum

What do you think?

dalewdalew Posts: 491
in PSA Set Registry Forum
The Ultimate Opening???
1st Finest Set - 1981 Baseball Fleer Basic - Retired
1st Finest Set - 1981 Baseball Fleer Master - Retired
1st Finest Set - 1955 Baseball Golden Stamps - Cleveland Indians - Retired
1st Finest Set - Mel Harder Baseball Master - Active
Mel Harder Showcase Set - Active
#15 on Current Set Registry - 1972 Topps Baseball - Retired
#23 on All Time Set Registry - 1972 Topps Baseball - Retired

Comments

  • theBobstheBobs Posts: 1,136 ✭✭
    As long as there are greedy sellers and greedy buyers, auctions like this will always appear.
    Where have you gone Dave Vargha
    CU turns its lonely eyes to you
    What's the you say, Mrs Robinson
    Vargha bucks have left and gone away?

    hey hey hey
    hey hey hey
  • MickeyCMickeyC Posts: 153
    In defense of this seller, he does run some interesting auctions. He ran a similar auction where he was auctioning lots of 4 cards for $10 a lot. I bid on several lots and ended up with some great cards.

    For $100 I got these:

    1959 Spahn AS - Ex/MT

    1968 B Williams - Ex/MT

    1958 8 Hi's, including Clemente (EX), and #446 an SP

    1962 2 semi hi's

    1963 Staub RC

    1965 Red Sox team card, semi hi

    plus 25 others


    I was very pleased with this guy's auctions, and this was the second time I participated in his auctions. The first time, I came a little short in the cards I won, compared to what I paid. But, with the nature of these type auctions, that will happen.

    Mark

  • BigKidAtHeartBigKidAtHeart Posts: 1,799 ✭✭
    here is the reply I got from one of the previous
    buyers of these packs... who left him a Neutral
    (so I asked him what was wrong!)

    Hello:
    I had no problem with the seller as far as communication, delivery and
    quality of product. All cards received were in good to excellent condition
    and each was individually covered in plastic. My disappointment came from
    the players that I received. After reading his description I thought that I
    would receive one, maybe two well known players. This is what I received.

    Willie Crawford
    John Werhas
    Tom Parsons
    Don Buddin
    Milwaukee Braves team photo
    Jim Hegan
    Howie Nunn
    Tommie Sisk
    Bob Dustal
    Tom Butters
    Dave Morehead
    Dan Schneider

    Certainly not household names nor everyday starters. Only Hegan and Sisk
    had fair careers. I guess you get what you pay for.

    Hope this helps.
    Gary
    imageimage
  • VirtualizardVirtualizard Posts: 1,936 ✭✭
    Overall, the guy does have pretty good feedback. Every time I see a dutch auction of this sort, I am always apprehensive. I bid on one about a year ago just to see what I would get (not this seller) - only $10 or so - I got nothing worthwhile. This auction may not be that bad given his feedback - 1000+ buyers can't all be idiots and you would expect a few negatives on auctions of this type. I won't bid, but if I were looking for these cards, I might be tempted. Just my thoughts.

    JEB.
  • MickeyCMickeyC Posts: 153
    Got my cards in from this auction. I'm so-so pleased. Each 4 card pack cost me $19.95:

    Pack #1:
    61T #521 EX
    65T #316 VG/EX
    68T #312 EX
    58T #23 VG

    Pack #2:
    59T #43 VG
    65T #315 VG/EX
    69T #23 VG
    68T #355 EX (Ernie Banks)

    Pack #3:
    59T #42 VG
    61T #157 EX/MT
    68T #311 EX
    60T #148 EX (Yaz rookie!)

    Pack #4:
    58T #380 G/VG
    60T #71 VG/EX
    63T #65 EX
    65T #266 EX/MT

    Pack #5:
    58T #373 VG/EX
    63T #64 G
    69T #649 VG/EX
    68T #505 EX

    Pack #6:
    69T #24 VG/EX
    61T #187 VG
    59T #487 EX
    65T #260 VG/EX (Drysdale)

    Pack #7:
    59T #486 VG
    63T #58 VG
    65T #314 VG
    60T #539 VG

    Pack #8:
    61T #183 EX
    65T #268 EX
    69T #25 VG
    55T #193 G/VG (Johnny Sain/Yankee)

    Pack #9:
    63T #37 VG
    62T #6 VG/EX
    60T #70 EX/MT
    55T #95 EX/MT

    Pack #10:
    69T #26 VG
    60T #171 VG/EX
    59T #485 VG/EX (Ryne Duren/Yankee)
    63T #488 EX

    If it weren't for the Yaz rookie, and the Banks, this would have been a bust. I think it's about a $150 lot of cards, and I'm ok with losing $50 on a "pot luck" kind of auction.

    Mark

Sign In or Register to comment.