"Guess the PCGS grade" Ebay auction!

rkfish

Something new......not sure if it will help the seller though.Guess the grade

moursund

Looks lackluster, with a weak strike.

am

BigD5

Whaddya say there Steve? MS/63? Looks about there. Can't tell the luster though. If the coin only graded ms/61, he'll do ok. The coin looks ok.
Different, that's for sure.

Russ

One of the forum members here, I believe it was jtryka, did this a while back with a couple PCGS slabs.

Russ, NCNE

DCAMFranklin

A sure-fire method of selling your coin for too little money!

Probably another seller fed up with the inconsistency of the PCGS grade.

paigowjohnny

I don't know Peace dollars too well, but looks pretty close to the 63 I have...

gmarguli

Looks AU58. The fact that the seller capitalized "uncirculated coin" makes me think it did come back AU58.

jtryka

Yes, I did this a while back with some modern proofs I think. It was fun, and maybe I'll bid on this one, I like Peace dollars!

MadMarty

Looks like a real weak strike on the obverse. I'll go with an AU58.

CLASSICS

wow.....here we go again....guess the grade from the seller, yet he does say it is b.u. is that suppose to mean ms60... whatever the holder says, it looks washed out and lackluster, i would grade it au 55 maybe au58.

rkfish

funny.....I was thinking a 63 but the obv/rev centers look very weak but it's probably the pics.

Can't believe anyone would run an auction for this date in 64 or up without listing the grade. My final answer if it's truely BU is a 62!
It is an interesting (and different) way to run your auction.

Jtryka......how did your auctions do?