Is this toned Morgan real or AT?

Russ

Large scans here:

Really gigantic obverse.

Really gigantic reverse.

I posted this coin a few months ago, but it was one of my early efforts at capturing toning, so the shots were suckily inaccurate. These are about as close as one can get to what the coin actually looks like.

What do you guys think?

Russ, NCNE

braddick

I vote for real toning. The luster appears to be coming from underneath the coin.

FC57Coins

2 votes for real

danglen

Looks real to me!! Yellow, magenta, cyan is the right sequence

CLASSICS

make that 3 votes for ...real...it looks original and natural.

Morganluver

Looks legit to me as well. The colors seem to be the right hues.

nwcs

Looks fine to me.

Russ

Cool! I have a real toned Morgan. I'm a member of the club!

Russ, NCNE

nwcs

>Is this toned Morgan real or AT?

Actually, it's memorex!

1jester

Beautiful Morgan, Russ. I think the toning is real too.

LucyBop

The Toning is real, the only problem I see is the coin is a counterfit!

MacCoin

looks real to me

Russ

Lucy,

There are some genuine coins that don't have Ben on them.

Russ, NCNE

LucyBop

<< <i>There are some genuine coins that don't have Ben on them. >>



Ohhh, okay, that explains it......

prooflike

yeah, it's real or faked well enough to look real

Pushkin

Both.






Caveat - I know nothing about silver.

CoinResource

Looks real!! I gotta couple just liek that one, only a little darker. -cr

mr1931S

this dollar appears to have gotten it's toning when toning wasn't so cool...it looks alot like many a toned Morgan dollar did about 20 years ago...

...underlying luster trying to escape through...soft rainbow colors apparent but not like someone painted them on...and deep gold colors without looking like they was burned on...

must have gotten its toning over 20 years ago,Russ...

dorkkarl

it's the kind of a-t that long-term storage in whitman albums causes. terrific look, it's a keeper.

K S