here's another "you decide which one"

1907Quarter

bustcap1
bustcap2

kieferscoins

I want to pick #1, but the picture is so dark, it may be hiding something.

Cameron Kiefer

littlewicher

I would pick #2, simply because you can actually see the coin.

braddick

My pick is #1. I bet it's not as dark in person and #2 appears to have ever so slight corrosion.

lathmach

The first one looks to be an 1832 as the headline states. The description says 1831 though.
The pic is too poor to judge this coin.
The 1834 may well be the rarest variety for that year, but its still only somewhat scarce as a variety. None of the 1834's are hard to find.

Ray

Rotts

Heck get both. Rotts

ClarkOfKent

Ok, here's a fair comparison of them.




Clark

1907Quarter

is the corrosion on the cheek and field just below nose? #2 that is.
How did that second image appear???!

1907Quarter

#1 has a nice original look to it, does it not? Certainly atleast F-15 and problem free. Would you agree?

airplanenut

Liberty looks ready to hurl in #2... I go with #1

prooflike

Thanks Braddick, that is what is wrong with #2... it just didn't look right to me and I couldn't figure it out and I think you are correct, it does appear to be slightly corroded.

Even though the image is dark, #1 appears to be the better of the two.

Good luck