opinion needed on this 84 Morgan

toners

Bidding on this raw 84P morgan, let me know what you think about toning, looks like album to me. Thanks in advance
Allen

FC57Coins

Looks pretty real to me - though I've made some blunders in the past.

Frank

Gilbert

It does look like album toning, but, a reverse image may be helpful to you too.

Dog97

If the rev looks similiar I'll go with album too. The color is kinda dull & flat like it has been cleaned & has retoned. Might just be the scan.

KlectorKid

i agree with dog i dont see very much luster.

clevegreg

I agree with the luster comments, and the colors of the toning and their clearly defined "bands" put up a warning flag for me. I would ask for a larger scan if you can.

Greg

Gilbert

You guys are right about the luster. I just took it the typical "P" mint later die state, with the associated weakness or flat relief and lackluster appearance. I also reserved those comments as "toners" seemed to ask specifically about the toning only.

Dog97

I've got one that looks similiar. DSC01169.jpg is from a dig cam while the other pict is from a scanner. 300-a is a straight scan while 300-a 2 is where I clicked "quick fix". Looks like 3 different coins don't it?

toners

Thanks for the comments, I did'nt notice the lack of luster, I think I will stay away from this one because from the boards collective comments it was probably dipped years ago and then album toned. DOG97, them was some good pic's
Thanks
Allen

Dog97

I'm not saying to stay away from it, just keep an open mind. As you can see from my picts you can't always see luster in a scan. I will say mine is toned only on 1 side and probably wouldn't pass muster @ PCGS. I think mine prolly laid up in a jewelry box & toned that way but who knows.

toners

DOG97, thanks, probably being who the seller is whom I won't mention along with the boards comments will lean me toward staying away from this coin, I know that this seller has sold AT coins in the past.
Thanks
Allen