Check out this auction (title). Slam to PCI.

goose3

sad but no doubt true

JJacks

Man, I wish more people would see some of these and realize why they should by PCGS/NGC/ANACS and simply forget most of the others. I do give the sellers credit there for not trying to hype that coin up!

JJacks

airplanenut

The only problem is when someone buys it and resells it as a 69... why don't they just recertify it?

DHeath

Although I don't care whose plastic a nice coin is holdered in, sometimes I do get a kick out of comparing pics of similar grades from different companies. In the pics below, coin #1 is graded PR70Cam and coin #2 is graded PR69 Cam. Based on Teletrade's pics, which would you prefer raw. Hey, maybe all the crud is dust on the holder.

1964 Kennedy PR70Cam
1964 Kennedy PR69Cam


PS - the first one is IGC, and the second is PCGS.

wingedliberty

Superior should know better
Brian

BigD5

That's puzzling. I don't think Superior is going to find too many seasoned Buffalo nickel Proof collectors willing to purchase that type of coin "sight unseen" with their "terms". I'm glad I don't buy anything from them anyway. We should email them, looking for the ACG slabbed "bargain" lots

Gilbert

Do they accept consignments, and if so, should they just tell the consignee "your coin is in a cr@p slab and we aren't going to handle it?" Suppose that person also has high dollar coins in more reputable slabs too? Shouldn' t they just accept the consignment and let the buyer decide if it is acceptable or not?

You may substitute consignment with "placed for auction".

MICHAELDIXON

Superior grades the coin 65, even though it's in a PCI 69 holder. This one surprised me! I didn't think Superior would sell something like that in a PCI holder!

braddick

I appreciate Superior selling the COIN and the heck with the holder. It appears to them, the PCI holder is simply a Capital plastics coin holder.
Cool.