Opinions wanted on 1917 Ty1 SLQ

Flash

I am wondering what others think of the coin pictured here, given its PCGS grade. What would be a fair amount to offer a seller for this coin? Greysheet does not list bid/ask prices for FH examples, so I don't know how much this coin is really worth. Thanks.

Placid

Here is a link to a pcgs 65 FH but the prices for 64fh are given.

Link

mbbiker

I would say between $300-350
just a guess
(whatever you and the buyer feel ok with?)

Cam40

Its wonderful.Did you search online auctions to compare similar pieces prices?
I.d guess its worth in the 1k area?Probably more on the open market.

I dont guess this will be a giveaway coin in the future?

itsnotjustme

$350 to $400 is my estimate...

Flash

Thanks. I've been checking the selling prices for other 64FH examples, but they seem to be all over the place. My next question is.. how close is the "Heritage Value Index" to the real world?

Cam40

Thats the one showing a price to be more in-line with the pocketbook than the compared prices of the CU and Numismedia guides?
I think they are more `real world` than the ones mentioned,yes.

dragon

Flash,

The Heritage Value Index is actually quite accurate and a good tool for pricing many coins. Occasionally it is a bit on the low side which reflects wholesale transactions, but for the most part is very close for average quality coins.

Dragon

dorkkarl

seems like an awful lot of the 1917's have full-head detail. i wouldn't think there'd be much premium.

K S