PCGS graded AT coin?

byergo

Looks a little bit fishy!

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=1375984328

mrdq

link

MrLee

Why?

Dog97

What looks fishy about it?

byergo

It reminds me of heat/oven toning. Perhaps not?

itsnotjustme

I've had a silver eagle tone, but it was unattractive. I used it for dipping practice!

supercoin

Yeah, and look at that shill bidder! *


* Edited to note I was the high bidder at the time I posted.

Dave99B

Kind of pleasent to look at, but clearly AT. PCGS blew it.

Dave

FC57Coins

LOL - you guys kill me!!!!

dorkkarl

ALL coins with wild-n-crazy colors is artificially toned. some are just accepted more than others. natural tone for silver is GRAY.

if you like it, buy it! who cares what someone else thinks

K S

prooflike

Definitely looks AT. WOnder how it got slabbed..

agentjim007

If a coin is toned all the AT critics come out of the woodwork. If a coin is white it must have been dipped. You just can't win.

Morganluver

You guys are a laugh a minute. It's absoutely genuine. It looks envelope toned and these tone very quickly because they are almost pure silver .999%. Please keep saying it's AT though and maybe it will go cheaply although I believe you have already tipped off the people in the know.