Options
Grading help: harshly cleaned vs green bean
I’m still starting out and would love some pointers from the experts. I sent in a raw 89-cc Morgan to PCGS and just got it back “harshly cleaned.” I also have a straight graded 89-cc with a green bean.
Looking at them side by side, nothing from the details coin jumps out at me as tremendously different. I’d love help with specifics so I can spot this in future. I’m happy to take additional photos or close ups if that would help.
Thanks as always!


1
Comments
If you slowly tilt the harshly cleaned example at different angles and rotate it under a good light source, you should see noticeable hairlines. Start by looking at the lighter colored areas on each side.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
You harshly cleaned one looks cleaned in your images. Unfortunately, the TrueView PCGS produced is over-exposed and essentially worthless.
If you look at the obverse field in front of Ms. Liberty's portrait there appear to be diagonal lines going through the field. These are almost certainly wipe marks on the coin. The reverse also has an odd sheen especially around "STATES" and "ONE DOLLAR" and it is kind of reminiscent of when folks would use a pencil eraser on a coin. Straight on images are typically the best and it is again unfortunate that the TrueView is so poor.
In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson
I've added red ovals to areas that are most concerning, though the reverse appears really to be slightly pitted or more harshly worked on. Regardless, listen to @MFeld as he knows all of this inside-out and will explain it to you well. If you tilt the coin and look at the surfaces, not really how much detail is left, but the fabric of the surfaces, you will likely see a more pronounced sheen or hairlines on the cleaned piece.
If you have a mentor you could go to for in-person help that would be even better.
In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson
Besides the probable hairlines, the cleaned coin was dipped too white, esp as a Fine/VF, to pass.
The details looks overall shinier and more artificial than the CAC’d coin, which is a defining factor. Also considering the non-problem coin is a 35 versus the details coin being a 12 or 15, it's expected to have a slightly better look than the other 1889-CC.
"Another day, another Collectors Universe forum scrolling session."
- Someone, probably
This is exactly what my eye saw up front and what I'd have pointed to. I'm sure the effects of the cleaning are easier to see when rotating the coin under light (and seeing how the hairlines are more or less visible at different angles) but these light patches--contrasted with the less bright areas--stand out in the photos.
I will say that the CAC coin also looks rather light to me and at least my preference would be a coin with darker surfaces, but not knowing CAC's criteria or if in-hand the coin has a bit of a more original light grey look (and maybe some light lustre in the peripheral devices) I want to give CAC at least some benefit of the doubt.
The uneven nature of the color on the fields on the left coin shows the cleaning.
The right-hand coin is a more 'honest' example with a bit of skin. Lots of dings, but even, more likely from circulation, with the detail still being present. Obviously the detail on the 35 is much better as well.
dval2929,
Yes the one on the left is harshly cleaned, however this one is not.......right?
-
Your hobby is supposed to be your therapy, not the reason you need it.
@airplanenut I agree with your CAC assessment. Also thought it looked lighter then it should, probably from a light dip but MA all the same. When I see the dark circulation dirt in the ear, in the 889, some of the letters and CC but none in the fields, usually a sign of dipping. But light enough to not strip the surface luster. Probably looks a lot better in hand.
Proof-61 gold is expected to have excessive hairlines. Virtually a net grade for some kind of problem.
"But seek ye first the kingdom of God and His righteousness and all these things shall be added unto you" Matthew 6:33. Young fellow suffering from Bust Half fever.
BHNC #AN-10
JRCS #1606
Probably cleaned by burnishing. The reverse, especially, has the "look".
Right click on your images>Open in new tab>Click + magnifying glass


You will be able to see much better.
Try to visualize what coins look like if they haven't been messed with by people trying to remove surface dirt, toning, spots, etc.. "Original skin" is one term by collectors for coins that have not been stripped with chemicals or abrasive materials. Think of scouring a cooking pan and how using a metal scouring pad vs. a plastic one would damage the surface.
I know from your comment in another thread that you think that this coin has been cleaned and shouldn’t have received a straight grade. But you’re ignoring the fact that gold is a softer metal. And gold coins are more easily hairlined, without having been cleaned.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
I concur. I think "Harshly Cleaned" as a condition descriptor are too strong of words of disapproval for this piece, however. I would crack it and send to a different service if it were my coin.
”Isn't learning fun?"
The Learning Channel
Thanks, everyone, for your help. It’s still not “slap me in the face” obvious but I’m slowly getting it thanks to your comments here 🙏
And that it’s a proof with different surface texture.
What do you use for magnification? Rotating the coins in hand under magnification will show obvious differences on the coin surfaces. This following video on youtube shows magnification examples
https://youtube.com/watch?v=mB-HxQSOi6Y