Show Report and Some NEWPS
I attended the monthly Melbourne FL show this past Sunday, the first one in a long time, (as some of the dealers mentioned), as other obligations have kept popping up. As it’s only 15 minutes away, I really have no excuse….
I arrived 10 minutes early, and the main public parking lot was fairly sparse, which I thought wasn’t a good sign.
After getting my name tag and raffle ticket, I proceeded to the bourse entrance and waited with several others for the 9:30 general public starting time.
There are generally 30+ dealers set up, most in the main hall, with a few others in the adjacent overflow room. A lot of the same old faces, but invariably some new dealers set up as well. And as usual, I do most of my business with the same 3-4 guys…
Observations: The public soon showed up in force and the place got busy. Dealer to dealer business was active, and retail sales were taking place. A lot of that was people buying silver bullion at the current lower prices. Dealers seemed to be lightly stocked with bullion; either they didn’t bring much or have much. I saw several dealers sell out what they had, if the price was at or slightly above spot.
Better collector coins in general were priced strong, like price guide +. Talking to a dealer friend who gets around, and he said he has to pay over Bid for just about anything interesting, so that’s what the market is.
I had to leave at 11:15 to meet my wife, and the place was full, and people were still coming in the door. The guys at the entrance said attendance was over 150 by that time, pretty good for a small one day monthly show.
Newps. I did manage to find a few coins at what I felt were reasonable prices. My first purchase was a better date walker, the low mintage ‘29D. I didn’t need it, but I’m a sucker for pre-35 walkers in higher circ grades, and this AU has a nearly full thumb. It was priced a little high, and he offered a small discount, so I passed. He asked me to make an offer, I hesitated, so he countered his own price with a substantial discount, which I jumped on. It probably helped that he was acquiring a nice group of Barber halves in PCGS holders from another dealer and probably needed the cash.

I can now say that I’ve paid 2x price guide for a nicely toned coin. I was going to do a stand alone post on it, titled “crazy insane monster toned undergraded commem!”, to see if I could draw @MarkFeld’s ire 😉, but the forum doesn’t need any more clickbait and I don’t need anyone’s ire! There are members who truly do own spectacular coins, (and I’m not one of them), who don’t boast about them, which is as it should be.
Bear in mind, the price guide is sub-$30 for AU Columbia halves, so I’m not buried in it, but I’ve wanted a decent Columbian toner for awhile for my type set, and this fits.

The same dealer had a number of interesting coins, mostly in older holders. A lot of it was dark side, as well as lower to mid/grade US type. He indicated he was a motivated seller, so I kicked some tires. This coin caught my eye pretty quickly, for the holder and the coin, the price was fair, so I had him set it back. 


I looked at a fair number of other coins, some I was interested in but I couldn’t make the price work. This one was an exception, nothing special, but I liked the holder, the coin, and the price.

Comments
Nice report and love the crusty purchases!
Nice show report. I need to get to the Melbourne show one of these days, although I'm not nearly as close as you are. That 20c pickup really caught my eye, as I have one with remarkably similar color also in an OGH starting in "443".
(forgive the photo quality—I don't have the coin in hand so these are screenshots of a video)

Superb collections are built more by omission than by addition.
That double dime has a very solid liberty. The liberty is not incused but raised up unlike other seated series. So to have a full liberty even at vf20 is a plus
The good news is that @MarkFeld isn’t a forum member, so you couldn’t draw his ire, even if you wanted to.
The not so good news is that @MFeld is a member and has seen your post.😉
Well done on your show report and your pickups.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
Thanks, and I agree.
I perused auction records, and was surprised to see partial LIBERTY examples even at the VF 30 level.
The dealer likewise considered it under graded, but there isn’t a big price spread, so we were able to get to a fair price for both of us pretty quickly.
Enjoyable post and congratulations on some nice purchases.
@Walkerguy21D said-
There are members who truly do own spectacular coins, (and I’m not one of them), who don’t boast about them
I wish they would I love seeing spectacular coins on this forum. Theres a difference between sharing and boasting.
Student of numismatics and collector of Morgan dollars
Successful BST transactions with: Namvet Justindan Mattniss RWW olah_in_MA
Dantheman984 Toyz4geo SurfinxHI greencopper RWW bigjpst bretsan MWallace logger7 JWP BruceS bigjpst
JWP PROMETHIUS88
Great report, my friend.
Very nice strike on that 29-D. It’s just a whisper away from mint state.
I really like that double dime, in the OGH, as well. A lot of meat for a VF 20 and I like the color on it.
Sometimes, it’s better to be LUCKY than good. 🍀 🍺👍
My Full Walker Registry Set (1916-1947):
https://www.ngccoin.com/registry/competitive-sets/16292/
Nice report. I like the Columbian half. Nice toning for a circ.
Thanks for your report. Nice coins.
Glad you were able to find a wide variety of nice coins at a small show.
Excellent pick ups!
Edit to add- I really like the look of that 20C, and you don't see those too often.
Collector, occasional seller
Wow!! That 20-center is super nice for a VF... nicely done. No copper this go around?
Successful BST transactions with: SilverEagles92; Ahrensdad; Smitty; GregHansen; Lablade; Mercury10c; copperflopper; whatsup; KISHU1; scrapman1077, crispy, canadanz, smallchange, robkool, Mission16, ranshdow, ibzman350, Fallguy, Collectorcoins, SurfinxHI, jwitten, Walkerguy21D, dsessom.
That was what I thought when I spotted it; I love OGHs anyway, and seeing an unusual coin in one made it hard to resist!
No copper this go around?
Nope, but I looking for it!
Virtually nothing early, one raw details 1794 listed as R6 that I didn’t even quote, given everything that dealer had was moon money. An 1813 in an OGH Graded F12, but was clearly once corroded then burnished, no way it would straight grade today. A few early middle dates but lower grade, a couple ubiquitous 1837 1838’s, and a few generic late dates in AU.
Great report. That .20 piece is flat amazing!!! Nice pickups.
Dave