Williams, Maye or Nix?

craig44

Now that we are 2 complete regular seasons into their young careers, who would you choose out of those 3 QB's?

I can see positives for all 3, but I take Maye. I know, homer here!

I think Nix is good, but is riding a fantastic defense. I think Caleb is closer to Maye though. if he can improve his accuracy next year they could be neck and neck. I think Caleb is faster/better scrambling and arm talent is very close between the two.

perkdog

Drake Maye and it's not even close

Williams second then Nix

2dueces

@perkdog and I knew Drake Maye was going to be a stud. Not that I care about personal gain ( of course I do) but my $600 investment in his rookie cards will be a nice confirmation

perkdog

@2dueces said:
@perkdog and I knew Drake Maye was going to be a stud. Not that I care about personal gain ( of course I do) but my $600 investment in his rookie cards will be a nice confirmation

You were spot on my friend!!

Basebal21

Maye and then flip a coin on the other two. Both will make great plays and then make plays where you wonder why theyre on the field. Williams has the most talented offense, Nix has the best defense, yet Maye still had the best season

BLUEJAYWAY

Maye.

galaxy27

Maye is a stud. plays like a grizzled vet.

Caleb has made great strides because he's being nurtured by a dude who actually knows how to coach. if Eberflus was still the HC, Caleb would probably look like Geno Smith's half-brother. the thing i love most about him is that he doesn't turn it over very often. a ~4:1 ratio after two seasons. but he's still a work in progress, still not completely polished.

Nix: see Williams, Caleb. glimpses, but at this juncture he's not Maye either.