... also commemorating the police officers who lied under oath plus the FBI informants who also entered the building and were not prosecuted. IMO, the only good thing about that medal is its very attractive design.
Other than @fiftysevener 's slightly more subtle political comment, this thread has dodged raindrops and stayed pretty apolitical. Impressive considering the topic.
Why am I not surprised this poster decided to air his political views inappropriately?
I see very few apolitical posts on this thread. They are almost all political, though mostly subtle. What do you think the references to Ft Sumter and DOGE are?
Throw em all in jail I say. The Collectors Universe U.S. Coin Forum is no place for politics. RGDS!
If the U.S. Coin Forum is no place for politics...why are so many coins covered with politicians/presidents ? You can only mention details of George Washington's bust, but do not mention why he's being honored on the quarter and what he stood for? It's okay to put the Capitol or Lincoln Memorial on coins and medals, but do not mention what happens inside those institutions ? I agree, this is no place for political arguments, but sometimes politics are just a natural spin on some of our designs.
@4Redisin said:
Our government issues a medal for an event, and we cannot discuss anything related to the event without ruffling the feathers of the less informed who believe that trying to educate them is a political statement.
I read the rules, Politics is against the rules; and I have a "target" (OMG - that's gun related!) on my back because of the way I post. I will not give anyone here a reason to flag my posts unjustly. IMO, that is a very attractive medal for an event that is very misunderstood.
Your "education" is not related to US coins and was directly a political statement, whether one agrees with it or not.
I'll only speak for myself; I don't want your education and the presumption that you have anything to teach, particularly about that event is beyond absurd. That's saying something considering your other posts.
The mods agree as your post was deleted. You don't have a target on your back. You're just who you are. That is plenty.
I apologize to the mods and all here for posting about a politically inspired medal. I gave myself a weeklong ban to post on my other forums.
But the question of what is worthy of honor is at issue. There are legitimate debates about whether statues who honor certain individuals should be removed or allowed to remain, and this is on "both sides". This is the same issue but involves coins and/or medals. Readers here may be split on the Jan 6th medals but I have to think that honoring Jackie Robinson and Navajo Code Talkers would be less controversial. Should we be cancelling all of these coins and medals after Congress (our representatives) authorized them on our behalf? What do you think?
Collector and dealer in obsolete currency. Always buying all obsolete bank notes and scrip.
Comments
"G-d save the King"
Of course I am referring to the Loyalists in Nova Scotia who would not have appreciated the Washington Before Boston medal.
My latest for the ANA, which is on this very topic: https://readingroom.money.org/controversy-surrounds-january-6-medals/
The title of this thread is misleading. The item in question is for sale; however, the marketing language has been revised.
If the U.S. Coin Forum is no place for politics...why are so many coins covered with politicians/presidents ? You can only mention details of George Washington's bust, but do not mention why he's being honored on the quarter and what he stood for? It's okay to put the Capitol or Lincoln Memorial on coins and medals, but do not mention what happens inside those institutions ? I agree, this is no place for political arguments, but sometimes politics are just a natural spin on some of our designs.
I apologize to the mods and all here for posting about a politically inspired medal. I gave myself a weeklong ban to post on my other forums.
Hmmm, how can I make a political statement without making a political statement....................
"When they can't find anything wrong with you, they create it!"
This was a very good way to drum up support for a medal, maybe they should pull the Kabul medal for a few weeks and alert the press about it.
I'm shocked this thread is still open and no one was jailed. I did a two week stretch for talking politics on the PM forum.
Philippians 4:4-7
I think that we are keeping it civil.
But the question of what is worthy of honor is at issue. There are legitimate debates about whether statues who honor certain individuals should be removed or allowed to remain, and this is on "both sides". This is the same issue but involves coins and/or medals. Readers here may be split on the Jan 6th medals but I have to think that honoring Jackie Robinson and Navajo Code Talkers would be less controversial. Should we be cancelling all of these coins and medals after Congress (our representatives) authorized them on our behalf? What do you think?
Give it a rest. It's fake news.
Orson Welles?
The Mysterious Egyptian Magic Coin
Coins in Movies
Coins on Television
Coin World posted an article on this. BTW, they are still on sale as of today. Bought some.
https://usmint.gov/united-states-capitol-police-and-those-who-protected-the-us-capitol-on-january-6-2021-bronze-medal-MASTER_MDJ6.html