Silver Eagles On Ebay
Delorean
Posts: 476 ✭✭✭
What's up with some sellers listing buy it now silver eagles for $22-$24 with free shipping? obvious scams but anyone deal with these people?
Chuck,
Ever Onward
Ever Onward
0
Comments
Scam.
Don't waste your time.
Could you provide the ID number please.
Here's one:
https://www.ebay.com/itm/196730078653
I reported it, report it as well, as it often takes multiple eBay reports to get one removed.
315864966359
Ever Onward
I might add...eBay of course didn't find my report a violation. LoL. So if a few more of you can report it super...
315864183006
Ever Onward
395809903269
Ever Onward
Lot's of Chinese fakes on ebay...silver plated brass crap.
bob
The listing is absolutely NOT a violation. It is almost definitely a scam, but there's no indication of our on the listing. You've got a picture of a real coin. You have to assume that you're going to get a different, fake coin. But how is ebay supposed to determine that from the listing?
Lots of legitimate businesses actually do sell these back of spot to acquire names and addresses. So even the low price can't be assumed to indicate fraud.
someone on the pm forum took a flyer thinking the seller had a problem. we talked the forumite into reversing charges, getting a new cc, etc.
that's the closest i've heard.
and it's hard to buy for counterfeit investigation because 1) who knows how many counterfeit creators there are (each order $$ adds up) and 2) i just couldn't bring myself to risk a cc on even a single transaction
(do the cc companies still generate on time use cc numbers?)
agree that the listing is not in violation.
if a deal is too good to be true, it's too good the be legal (L.E. personnel on American Greed tv show)
but i can't report the non-violation.
one seller selling fake morgan's with real pictures had so many negs that i reported one still listed that had several negs associated with it. there were several other similar listings. ebay actually nuked the listing. some (too much) time later, the ebat id was naru'd
point? if you do fing someone with negatives adding up, alert ebay to the listing with negs and tell the what you think is happening
Fake coins need to have "Copy" stamped on them. It's in the rule book. I'm sure they got a good deal on ASE's. LoL.
From Hong Kong, a hard pass here
the picture is a real ase
A zero feedback seller to boot...
K
ebay is awash in get rich quick ebay coin sellers with zero feedback
i have found some with sales of their $300 pocket change, but I suspect those are shills
"Inspiration exists, but it has to find you working" Pablo Picasso
They are showing a picture of a real coin. We're all assuming he'll be shipping a fake coin. However there is nothing in the listing other than a real coin and a bargain price. Hence, there is no violation in the listing.
I just reported all three listings noted on this thread.
Hopefully they will be gone by this afternoon.
It’s like flogging a dead horse reporting listings from China.There are literally hundreds of sellers who have multiple accounts. If you report one listing and it is taken down, they simply move it to one of their other accounts and you have to start over again.
“ Hence there is no violation in the listing”
Yes there is, they are using stock photos which is against eBay policy. You are supposed to show clear photos of both sides of the coin that is listed.
That's not true. They have multiples available. They can use a "stock photo" for a commodity. Apmex and others do for silver eagles.
It is a waste of time reporting this. There's nothing wrong with the listing. It is more likely to get you put on their unreliable reporter list so that they don't take you seriously later.
Wasn't a waste of time. All three have been removed. Not on the "Unreliable Reporter List" yet.
You are right about larger dealers like APMEX, DBS Coin etc. As they are established dealers who will stand behind their listings so ebay gives them a by. You can also post stock photos along as you show photos of the product being sold.
What you cannot do is just post stock photos. This is to help prevent the selling of counterfeits. If you could just post stock photos, every cointerfeit coin, bullion coin, bullion bar etc. would have a stock photo. On the ASE's, if they posted a photo of the coin you would be getting, you would probably see that is was not genuine.
k photos along as you show photos of the product being sold.
No one selling 500 ASEs is or should post a picture of each coin. And they are not required to for new merchandise.
i'm surprised they removed the listings
the only suspicion was the under-melt price, which is not a violation
I will not be reporting similar auctions. i only do it with 100% proof
"i'm surprised they removed the listings". I'm not
jmlanzaf
I agree with your posting for general items but coins and currency have their own little set of rules
What is the policy?
Replica, counterfeit, plated or clad bullion, including items described as German silver or nickel silver, can’t be sold on eBay
Listings must accurately describe the precious metal weight content, purity (fineness) and brand (refiner or mint) of the bullion item being sold
Listings must include a photo of both sides of the actual coin, bar, or other bullion item being sold
If the bullion item includes an assay card or certificate of authenticity (COA), the listing must include a picture of the COA and an accurate description of the packaging
https://www.ebay.com/itm/116021534043
are you going to report that one? if not, why not?
“are you going to report that one? if not, why not?
The answer is in my earlier posting that I guess you did not read.
read and slipped by the post-checker
I'm with the "stock photo" screen shot from jmlanzaf as showing it's not just certain businesses
No problem, you can believe whatever you want. That is your right.
I just go by eBay’s policy that coins or bullion must have a photo of both sides of the coin.
Ebay doesn't care if members are selling fakes or authentic, so long as they get their commission. If it's too good to be true it absolutely is. $22-24 for Chinese plated brass? No THKS!
The whole worlds off its rocker, buy Gold™.
BOOMIN!™
First of all, a vintage coin is not a monster box of silver eagles. There is nothing wrong with a stock photo for selling multiple new bullion coins.
That aside, this alleged rule protects no one. I can post the picture of a real eagle and and send you a fake one, if I'm scamming you.
I have and will continue to use stock images where appropriate.
Exactly. There is no other way you could list such an item.
I do it with new items all the time. I'm not going to list 50 separate new books with 50 different images.