103 NFL Players Rank Quarterbacks

erikthredd

https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/41001234/nfl-patrick-mahomes-lamar-jackson-caleb-williams-quarterbacks-ranking
I'll post just the results of those rankings below but there are some opinions on who the players picked in that ESPN article.

1. Who is the GOAT, and if it's not Mahomes, what does he have to do to get there?
   The GOAT vote results (see the article link for some of the detailed answers) :
   Brady: (85)
   Mahomes: (7)
   Several other players received votes.

2. Rank the top three current quarterbacks.
   The used a points system for these results :
   Mahomes: (291)
   Jackson: (124)
   Burrow: (51)
   Other top vote-getters: Buffalo Bills' Josh Allen (39) and New York Jets' Aaron Rodgers (32)

3. Which rookie QB will have the most successful career?
   The results:
   Williams (34)
   Daniels (30)
   McCarthy (10)
   Other top vote-getters: Atlanta Falcons' Michael Penix Jr. (8) and Denver Broncos' Bo Nix (8)

4. Most overrated quarterback?
   The results:
   Allen (11)
   Hurts (10)
   Tagovailoa (10)
   Other top vote-getters: Los Angeles Chargers' Justin Herbert (9), Jacksonville Jaguars' Trevor Lawrence (8), Cleveland Browns' Deshaun Watson (7), Arizona Cardinals' Kyler Murray (6) and San Francisco 49ers' Brock Purdy (6)

5. Most underrated quarterback?
   The results:
   Purdy (14)
   Stafford (14)
   Atlanta Falcons' Kirk Cousins (7)
   Lions' Jared Goff (7)
   Green Bay Packers' Jordan Love (7)
   Carolina Panthers' Bryce Young (7)
   Other top vote-getters: Herbert (6), Dallas Cowboys' Dak Prescott (4), Jackson (4), Hurts (4) and Tagovailoa (4)

6. Biggest trash-talking quarterback?
   The results:
   Allen (26)
   Mayfield (17)
   Rodgers (15)
   Other top vote-getters: Mahomes (11), Burrow (4) and Houston Texans' C.J. Stroud (4)

DocBenjamin

Current NFL players have little of no memory of watching Unitas, Montana, Marino or Elway.

perkdog

I don't agree that Lamar Jackson is above Burrow

erikthredd

@perkdog said:
I don't agree that Lamar Jackson is above Burrow

I could see where maybe Jackson's individual success and Burrow's recent games missed may have played a part in their thought process, there.

erikthredd

@DocBenjamin said:
Current NFL players have little of no memory of watching Unitas, Montana, Marino or Elway.

But isn't that really true in every sport? You could probably same the same about every generation of MLB,NBA & NHL players too, each one of those generations of players (and fans) have always thought that theirs was the best.

These days everything is the GOAT, its just replaced the word best.

perkdog

l> @erikthredd said:

@perkdog said:
I don't agree that Lamar Jackson is above Burrow

I could see where maybe Jackson's individual success and Burrow's recent games missed may have played a part in their thought process, there.

Possibly, I mean when Lamar is on he is tough to beat but overall I'd say Burrow is the better QB but his durability can't hold a candle to Lamar.

erikthredd

@perkdog said:
l> @erikthredd said:

@perkdog said:
I don't agree that Lamar Jackson is above Burrow

I could see where maybe Jackson's individual success and Burrow's recent games missed may have played a part in their thought process, there.

Possibly, I mean when Lamar is on he is tough to beat but overall I'd say Burrow is the better QB but his durability can't hold a candle to Lamar.

Those two MVP's probably swayed a lot of opinions. We need one of these two to slow down Kansas City's pace already, can't have the Chiefs catching up to NE's 6 rings and Brady's 7 too soon. 😎

pdoidoi

@erikthredd said:

@perkdog said:
l> @erikthredd said:

@perkdog said:
I don't agree that Lamar Jackson is above Burrow

I could see where maybe Jackson's individual success and Burrow's recent games missed may have played a part in their thought process, there.

Possibly, I mean when Lamar is on he is tough to beat but overall I'd say Burrow is the better QB but his durability can't hold a candle to Lamar.

Those two MVP's probably swayed a lot of opinions. We need one of these two to slow down Kansas City's pace already, can't have the Chiefs catching up to NE's 6 rings and Brady's 7 too soon. 😎

What we need is for the refs to start calling the obvious holding penalties .

erikthredd

@pdoidoi said:

@erikthredd said:

@perkdog said:
l> @erikthredd said:

@perkdog said:
I don't agree that Lamar Jackson is above Burrow

I could see where maybe Jackson's individual success and Burrow's recent games missed may have played a part in their thought process, there.

Possibly, I mean when Lamar is on he is tough to beat but overall I'd say Burrow is the better QB but his durability can't hold a candle to Lamar.

Those two MVP's probably swayed a lot of opinions. We need one of these two to slow down Kansas City's pace already, can't have the Chiefs catching up to NE's 6 rings and Brady's 7 too soon. 😎

What we need is for the refs to start calling the obvious holding penalties .

Not to go down that rabbit hole but NE got their share of calls for years, it happens.

pdoidoi

@erikthredd said:

@pdoidoi said:

@erikthredd said:

@perkdog said:
l> @erikthredd said:

@perkdog said:
I don't agree that Lamar Jackson is above Burrow

I could see where maybe Jackson's individual success and Burrow's recent games missed may have played a part in their thought process, there.

Possibly, I mean when Lamar is on he is tough to beat but overall I'd say Burrow is the better QB but his durability can't hold a candle to Lamar.

Those two MVP's probably swayed a lot of opinions. We need one of these two to slow down Kansas City's pace already, can't have the Chiefs catching up to NE's 6 rings and Brady's 7 too soon. 😎

What we need is for the refs to start calling the obvious holding penalties .

Not to go down that rabbit hole but NE got their share of calls for years, it happens.

Yeah, they also had many called against. It should not be like that in the playoffs.