Possible Proof 1858 Seated Quarter?

InGodWeTrustCoins

I sent this to PCGS thinking it might be an impaired proof. They did not grade it as such but I still feel like it looks more like a proof than a business strike. Does anyone have any input or diagnostics? Thank you!

Crypto

I do not think so, the clashing & die lines inside the eagles shield do not show up on known proofs. Also the fabric doesn’t say proof to these eyes.

Davidk7

Not sharp enough to be a proof IMO.

Davidk7

Edit: my comment posted twice for some reason so ignore this

gumby1234

Ita been cleaned.

291fifth

Harshly cleaned AU. Not Unc. by my standards.

InGodWeTrustCoins

@Crypto said:
I do not think so, the clashing & die lines inside the eagles shield do not show up on known proofs. Also the fabric doesn’t say proof to these eyes.

Thank you very much @Crypto. That makes sense to me.