Reggie White Rookie - Misprint... thoughts on value?

Shadynasty · June 26, 2024 4:58PM

I have a Reggie White rookie card, and the back is severely misaligned. So bad it shows around 40% of another player's card, including name and number.

I'd say the quality of the card is around a 7... the corners are nice, and the centering is pretty good, but the printing and color aren't perfect.

I'm wondering if the misprinted back makes this a unique card (similar to Frank Thomas NNOF - though obviously not as special as that one). Would PSA even grade it?

JoeBanzai · June 26, 2024 5:43PM

I don't think PSA will grade it as a "wrongback" but they would probably grade it as "OC".

A Reggie White fanatic might give you an extra (?) few bucks.

PatriotTrading · June 26, 2024 6:25PM

Not remotely close to the NNOF Frank Thomas. But yeah, a Reggie White collector would pay a potential 2x-5x premium. You just have to find the right buyer.

RufussCkingston · June 26, 2024 11:30PM

@JoeBanzai said:
I don't think PSA will grade it as a "wrongback" but they would probably grade it as "OC".

I'd think it would be a PD. But even if the back was normal, at best you are looking at a PSA 8, which is a $40 card....

PatriotTrading · June 27, 2024 12:01AM

@JoeBanzai said:
I don't think PSA will grade it as a "wrongback" but they would probably grade it as "OC".

A Reggie White fanatic might give you an extra (?) few bucks.

Based on a couple posts elsewhere, it will either get a miscut designation with another card showing on the back and/or rejected with a Do Not Holder.