Searching for a photo of a PSA graded example of a 1997 SP Authentic Tradition Montana/Rice dual au

Eastern_WA_Sports

I have spent hours trying to find a photo of a PSA graded example of this card. I just received mine back from PSA stating the authenticity of the signatures is questionable. The card is consistent with the SGC and BGS graded copies that I have been able to find. However, I have yet to find an example in a PSA slab. I know this is a long shot as it appears that only 3 copies have been graded by PSA. This card has been in my possession for a very long time. Being a pack pulled autograph, I don't understand how the card could be authentic, but the signature be questionable.

burghman

https://www.psacard.com/auctionprices/football-cards/1997-sp-authentic-traditions/j-montana-rice/values/476031

thedutymon11

@Eastern_WA_Sports said:
Being a pack pulled autograph, I don't understand how the card could be authentic, but the signature be questionable.

First, because now they get Your Money the 2nd 3rd ++ time you sub it, then all of a sudden the Sigs are good.

Question, Serious. How does your finding of the same Graded PSA Card help your cause? What are you going to do, look at the Other Cards Signatures and call the PSA Autograph experts.....Wrong?

Don't see how that helps, but maybe I'm missing something?

Thanks

YeeHaw!

Neil

Eastern_WA_Sports

@burghman said:
https://www.psacard.com/auctionprices/football-cards/1997-sp-authentic-traditions/j-montana-rice/values/476031

Thank you so much.

Eastern_WA_Sports

@thedutymon11 said:

@Eastern_WA_Sports said:
Being a pack pulled autograph, I don't understand how the card could be authentic, but the signature be questionable.

First, because now they get Your Money the 2nd 3rd ++ time you sub it, then all of a sudden the Sigs are good.

Question, Serious. How does your finding of the same Graded PSA Card help your cause? What are you going to do, look at the Other Cards Signatures and call the PSA Autograph experts.....Wrong?

Don't see how that helps, but maybe I'm missing something?

Thanks

YeeHaw!

Neil

I was only looking for a reference. Mostly because out of the 4 graded examples I have found, 3 were graded by BGS, and I have seen many Autographs that have been authenticated by Beckett that do not look authentic.

PatriotTrading

Post a picture of yours dual auto

Eastern_WA_Sports

@PatriotTrading said:
Post a picture of yours dual auto

I guess that would have helped. I don't know how to add to the OP Here is a photo of mine along with the label (with incorrect info)
that was returned.

miwlvrn

With the label saying TD2 Staubach/Aikman, first questions would be: Did the same submission order have a TD2 card and a TD3 card in it? And if the order has a TD2 card, is it slabbed inside a grading holder where the the label says TD3 Rice/Montana but the card is TD2 Staubach/Aikman? (i.e., processing error where they switched the cards and labels)

Eastern_WA_Sports

@Eastern_WA_Sports said:

@thedutymon11 said:

@Eastern_WA_Sports said:
Being a pack pulled autograph, I don't understand how the card could be authentic, but the signature be questionable.

First, because now they get Your Money the 2nd 3rd ++ time you sub it, then all of a sudden the Sigs are

@miwlvrn said:
With the label saying TD2 Staubach/Aikman, first questions would be: Did the same submission order have a TD2 card and a TD3 card in it? And if the order has a TD2 card, is it slabbed inside a grading holder where the the label says TD3 Rice/Montana but the card is TD3 Staubach/Aikman? (i.e., processing error where they switched the cards and labels)

No, this was the only card of this type in the order

SmithAuctionCo

You can see another PSA example here - https://www.psacard.com/cert/64193862

I'd submit to BGS and see what they say.