l

Mr_Colombo

.

291fifth

It just looks damaged to me.

JBK

Agree. Heavily damaged.

MWallace

Looks like a couple of blows with a hammer.

Manifest_Destiny

Badly damaged.

Manifest_Destiny

jmlanzaf

Very educational thread.

As Ricko would have said, "missed it again"

horseyride

PMD

johnny9434

What one can learn around here 👍

Tramp

There is a full moon.

bsshog40

Aggravating when someone posts a coin asking for opinions, doesn't like the responses that they are getting, so they delete everything and we're left with a clickbait title to nothing.

WQuarterFreddie

@bsshog40 said:
Aggravating when someone posts a coin asking for opinions, doesn't like the responses that they are getting, so they delete everything and we're left with a clickbait title to nothing.

Don't blame the OP. The question was asked and answered and there is no way for the OP to close a thread.

291fifth

I think someone was hoping for a valuable "error".

jmlanzaf

@WQuarterFreddie said:

@bsshog40 said:
Aggravating when someone posts a coin asking for opinions, doesn't like the responses that they are getting, so they delete everything and we're left with a clickbait title to nothing.

Don't blame the OP. The question was asked and answered and there is no way for the OP to close a thread.

But they could leave everything there for other people to see and learn. He wasn't exactly getting bashed by anyone.

mark_dak

@bsshog40 said:
Aggravating when someone posts a coin asking for opinions, doesn't like the responses that they are getting, so they delete everything and we're left with a clickbait title to nothing.

We don't really know if they didn't like the answer. Possibly in this case they did get their answer and attempted to close out the thread in the best possible manner allowed. Better title would be helpful with a possible with coin description and edit with something like "Answer accepted - Thanks"

Mark

Manifest_Destiny

@mark_dak said:

@bsshog40 said:
Aggravating when someone posts a coin asking for opinions, doesn't like the responses that they are getting, so they delete everything and we're left with a clickbait title to nothing.

We don't really know if they didn't like the answer. Possibly in this case they did get their answer and attempted to close out the thread in the best possible manner allowed. Better title would be helpful with a possible with coin description and edit with something like "Answer accepted - Thanks"

Mark

They didn't like the answer. They thought it was a mysterious die error on a Columbian expo medal like the one below. When in reality, someone beat it up with a hammer, which was obvious to everyone.

divecchia

@jmlanzaf said:
Very educational thread.

As Ricko would have said, "missed it again"

and he would have add, "another sleepless night"

Donato

Catbert

Best to quote the OP so history is preserved I guess. Just liked the dealer poster here from Houston who constantly edits his threads.

Catbert

His posts.

jmlanzaf

@divecchia said:

@jmlanzaf said:
Very educational thread.

As Ricko would have said, "missed it again"

and he would have add, "another sleepless night"

Donato

Sigh...I miss RickO

JBK

It looks like the OP decided that he was right and everyone here was wrong.

The medal is now on ebay, listed as a "countermark cud error rare".

https://www.ebay.com/itm/155786887104

telephoto1

Here's the "countermark" in question... obviously the hammered equivalent of a vise job. Everything is in reverse. Not sure what was hammered into the medal though. Any thoughts?