RESULTS: CONGRATS MR. SPUD! GTG on recent PCGS Submissions! Giveaway: Winner gets a silver round.

Jobessi

So here's how this giveaway works. GTG on this recent submission from PCGS. If you're off by a grade, that equals 1pt. 2 away=2pts, etc. Guessing a grade designation (PL, etc deducts 1 bonus point-this is a good thing).

The guesser with the least amount of points wins a 1oz Silver Round.
_
(Hint: 2 came back Details-Cleaned, and 1 came back environmental damage. If you guess a numeric grade on one of these, you get a point)

I will post results on Saturday. Have fun!

1921 PEACE

1897-S MORGAN

1886-S MORGAN

1900-S MORGAN

1888-P MORGAN

1887-S (A) MORGAN

1885-O MORGAN

1887-S (B) MORGAN

1madman

1) environmental damage
2) 58
3) cleaned
4) 64
5) 63
6) cleaned
7) 63pl
8) 62

You

1) XF environmental damage
2) 62
3) AU cleaned
4) 55
5) 62
6) AU cleaned
7) 61PL
8) 58

mattniss

1) Env Damage
2) AU55
3) UNC Details - Cleaned
4) MS63
5) MS64
6) AU Details - Cleaned
7) MS62PL
8) AU58

reimahon

1) Environmental Damage
2) 55
3) Cleaned UNC details
4) 64
5) 63
6) Cleaned AU
7) 62
8) 63

bsshog40

1) Environmental damage
2) MS63
3) Cleaned Unc Details
4) MS62
5) MS61
6) Cleaned Unc
7) MS61 PL
8) MS62

gumby1234

1- 55
2- environmental damage
3- 64
4- 63
5- Unc details cleaned
6- 63
7- 63 PL
8- Unc details cleaned

Top50SetBuilder

1 - ED/AU
2 - 62
3 - CL/UNC
4 - CL/AU
5 - 62
6 - 61
7 - 62
8 - 61

markinsd

1: Details rim clip/environmental damage
2. MS63
3. MS details/cleaned
4. MS63
5. MS64
6. MS details/cleaned
7. MS62PL
8. MS61

1Mike1

Environmental damage
AU53
AU 58 PL
Cleaned
MS62
MS61
Cleaned

Davidk7

1) AU Dets Env. Damage
2) 63 (love the crust on this)
3) UNC Dets Cleaned
4) 58
5) 62
6) 62
7) 62PL
8) UNC Dets Cleaned

FlyingAl

1) XF Details, Environmental Damage, 2% Rim Clip
2) MS63
3) UNC Details, Cleaned
4) MS63
5) MS62
6) MS62
7) MS63PL
8) UNC Details, Cleaned

U1chicago

1) AU details environmental damage
2) MS 62
3) Unc Details cleaned
4) AU 58
5) MS 64
6) Unc Details cleaned
7) MS 62 PL
8) AU 58

Mr_Spud

1 AU details environmental damage
2 MS 63
3 Unc Details cleaned
4 AU55
5 MS 65
6 Unc Details cleaned
7 MS 63 PL
8 MS64

2windy2fish

15
45
63PL
63
64
63PL
62PL
63

TorinoCobra71

1) AU Details - Environmental Damage
2) BU Details - Cleaned
3) MS64PL
4) BU details - Cleaned
5) MS63
6) MS64
7) MS64
8) MS64

bsshog40

gumby1234

@Jobessi Its Sunday.

Jobessi

Results:

1. 1921 Peace- Environmental Damage
2. 1897-s -MS 63
3. 1886-S- MS 62PL
4. 1900-S- AU53 (I didn't agree with this grade at all)
5. 1888-P-MS64
6. 1887-S- UNC Details (Cleaned)
7. 1885-O UNC Details (Cleaned)
8. 1887-s- MS63

It Looks like Mr. Spud got the closest! Send me a message with your shipping address and I will ship you the 1oz silver round.

gumby1234

Just goes to show how tough grading from pics can be.
Congrats to @MrSpud

bsshog40

That was fun! Thanks for the chance. Congrats to MrSpud!

dcarr

1) 1921 Peace (rim clip). I've seen worse environmental damage with a straight grade.
2) 1897-S Morgan MS64.
3) 1886-S Morgan MS details (DMPL) cleaned.
4) 1900-S Morgan AU55.
5) 1888 [P] Morgan MS63.
6) 1887-S [A] Morgan MS details cleaned.
7) 1885-O Morgan MS63 PL.
8) 1887-S [B} Morgan MS61.

Mr_Spud

Wow, thanks 🌞

1madman

7 is cleaned? Seriously? Someone please show me the area?