AITA?: Ebay'ers asking your opinion on raw card condition?
I receive several questions a month about my opinion about raw cards I sell on ebay. The cards I sell are modern. I scan the both sides of the card in a penny sleeve with an Epson V550. If there is an obvious defect, I either don't list or call it out, otherwise I use NM-MT to be conservative.
Most of the questions come from newbies with less than 200 feedback. I don't want to be a jerk, but even if I think the card is really nice I am hesitant to say so with ebay's seller unfriendly return policies. I think their real question is "Do you think it will a pull a 10?"
Am I overreacting? How do you respond to this question?