WTB 2017 ATB pucks

Che_Grapes

I have the entire set except 3 of 5 for the 2017 date. Will pay 150 per coin (bullion version)

jmlanzaf

Put this on the BST please

coiner

Wholesale buy is +$11 over on ANY pucks. You’re a little low my friend.

Che_Grapes

@coiner said:
Wholesale buy is +$11 over on ANY pucks. You’re a little low my friend.

I once was reprimanded for commenting on the price! But it doesn’t bother me. When you say 11 dollars do you mean per ounce or for the whole coin? I attended the Raleigh coin show and the 2017 pucks there (bullion versions) were asking 200 dollars and wouldn’t take a penny less. I sold some of my extras for 125 - 150 (depending on date, for example 2010 and 2012 dates go for higher than other dates - especially some like the volcano coin)
So while I realize these are bullion coins - it’s hard to find them for less than 200 these days. I tried to go fair deals and buy / sell / trade for reasonable prices but I seem to be the exception.

I have the entire series except for 3 of the 2017 dates - just hoping someone could help me fill these holes.

Che_Grapes

And I have extras so would trade
@jmlanzaf - I actually did intend to put this in the BST thread - my fault

NJCoin

@Che_Grapes said:

@coiner said:
Wholesale buy is +$11 over on ANY pucks. You’re a little low my friend.

I once was reprimanded for commenting on the price! But it doesn’t bother me. When you say 11 dollars do you mean per ounce or for the whole coin? I attended the Raleigh coin show and the 2017 pucks there (bullion versions) were asking 200 dollars and wouldn’t take a penny less. I sold some of my extras for 125 - 150 (depending on date, for example 2010 and 2012 dates go for higher than other dates - especially some like the volcano coin)
So while I realize these are bullion coins - it’s hard to find them for less than 200 these days. I tried to go fair deals and buy / sell / trade for reasonable prices but I seem to be the exception.

I have the entire series except for 3 of the 2017 dates - just hoping someone could help me fill these holes.

If it's hard to find them for less than $200 these days, how is $150 a "fair deal" for the seller?

Che_Grapes

@NJCoin - if they bought them in 2017 and paid ~90 to 110 / coin.
But agree it’s hard to find them under 200 now. I bought them when they came out and paid much less (note I’m speaking of bullion versions only)

NJCoin

@Che_Grapes said:
@NJCoin - if they bought them in 2017 and paid ~90 to 110 / coin.
But agree it’s hard to find them under 200 now. I bought them when they came out and paid much less (note I’m speaking of bullion versions only)

I'm sorry, but I never understood how what anyone ever paid for anything has to do with what is fair or reasonable in a given market. If they are worth $200 now, they are worth $200 now.

Would you be willing to pay someone $500 for them if they somehow paid $700 for them in 2017, to try to make the transaction "fair" to them? If not, how is $150 "fair" just because someone might have picked them up for $100 6 years ago?