Another Questionable Piece (Bust Dollar, tricky)
I hope this remains the right place to ask, you've all been so helpful about the "error" large cent I asked about. So a second challenge: I bought this dollar a year ago. Holed, the right weight, and silver, it looked real to me. I had the hole repaired skillfully, waited nearly a year for its return, it's the same coin (note ding/crack on rim), but now it looks wrong to me. I've shown it to half a dozen experienced dealers and they are split. It's on the way to grading but I just want to give someone a chance to predict whether my $ is to be fully wasted. Before and after photos here.