GTG and CAC bust halves

Pnies20

So a little game:

One coin is CAC and one is not. GTG and which one has the CAC sticker. I will make clarifying comments if you have questions based on the quality of the photos. Only thing I will say is that the light hair lining on the 1820 is on the holder and not the coin.

Leave a comment about what you like or don’t like about the coins!

1818

1820

cameonut2011

Don’t we theoretically need the grades if being asked to guess which stickered?

Pnies20

@cameonut2011 said:
Don’t we theoretically need the grades if being asked to guess which stickered?

Nah.

Which coin would sticker at the grade you believe it to be.

P0CKETCHANGE

1818–AU55
1820—AU53 CAC

Herb_T

Is this mark on the coin?

jayPem

1818 45 CAC
1820 40

Pnies20

@Herb_T said:
Is this mark on the coin?

Holder

lkeigwin

The 1818 is a 55 and did not CAC (but should have).

The 1820 is a 50 and CAC'd.
Lance.

Coinscratch

40 CAC
45

CircCam

1818 53 No CAC
1820 45 CAC

Nice coins

JBN

50, 45 CAC.

jclovescoins

55 CAC
53

cameonut2011

53
45 CAC

EarlyUS

They both look EF-40 to me,

Pnies20

Lots of varying guesses but most believed the 1820 to be a better grade than assigned. I agree and my pics don’t really do it justice. I believe it may have been assigned XF40 due to a soft strike. My next question is should I just send it to CAC or send it in for reconsideration 🤔

ThreeCentSilverFL

I would. I have a few CBH's with that pleasant look in similar grades with CAC's. And a couple more with the same look that I'll send in soon. Both of yours are very nice by the way. I really like that 1820 at the assigned grade...