Is this a overdate ?

bidask

ELuis

Here it is one with the overdate:

Per url-link:
https://coins.ha.com/itm/mexico/mexico-republic-8-reales-1875-4-oa-ae-au-details-tooled-pcgs-/a/61167-98194.s

HTH

JohnnyCache

Could it be a recut 5.
Hard to tell.

TwoKopeiki

@JohnnyCache said:
Could it be a recut 5.
Hard to tell.

Looking at the TV at high resolution it does appear to be a re-cut 5. So, a 5/5 variety.

bosox

Reminds me of a few Canadian cents, where the engraver tried to make letter or number repairs in the working die with a manual punch and accidently used a punch of a smaller font.

WildWestHalfDollars

5 over 5

syl

Like Bosox, I don't think it's a recut. The guy just smacked his hammer on a smaller font 5 punch. So yes, it's a 5/5. Nice find.