Payton rookie opinions

LandrysFedora

Any opinions on this one? It's my father in laws. Looks far from perfect starting with the top right corner but just wanted other opinions on it. Thanks.

handyman

Easy 6 could get 6.5-7 as it’s centered really nicely. Is that a wax stain on the back abouve Chicago? If so it may 5.

LandrysFedora

@handyman said:
Easy 6 could get 6.5-7 as it’s centered really nicely. Is that a wax stain on the back abouve Chicago? If so it may 5.

Thanks @handyman. Good catch! So hard to see with the naked eye. Here's a closer pic of that spot.

galaxy27

@LandrysFedora

you know what they say about a Sweetness rook...........it's like sex -- even when it's bad, it's still pretty good

nothing worse than a piece of cardboard that has framing issues from left to right on the front, and your specimen does not possess that problem

great card

maddux69

3-4 based upon the top right corner

82FootballWaxMemorys

I feel a 5, depending on the submitter will get 3-4 or 6. Presents nicely though due to left right centering.

LandrysFedora

@maddux69 said:
3-4 based upon the top right corner

Definitely that corner will affect it's grade if I send it in. It's up to my father in law, his card. Thanks for the imput.

LandrysFedora

@galaxy27 said:
@LandrysFedora

you know what they say about a Sweetness rook...........it's like sex -- even when it's bad, it's still pretty good

nothing worse than a piece of cardboard that has framing issues from left to right on the front, and your specimen does not possess that problem

great card

Thanks galaxy, still trying to figure whether it's worth subbing. It's my father in laws card.

LandrysFedora

@82FootballWaxMemorys said:
I feel a 5, depending on the submitter will get 3-4 or 6. Presents nicely though due to left right centering.

I was leaning a 5 myself with that top right corner being the main factor. Thanks for the imput @82FootballWaxMemorys.

RufussCkingston

at $200 it's not worth subbing, but for SGC at $30, then yes...

LandrysFedora

@RufussCkingston said:
at $200 it's not worth subbing, but for SGC at $30, then yes...

Thanks. I totally agree. If I sub it with psa it won't be until they return to their normal grading tiers.

ldferg

Looks like a great 6.

Ahmanfan

5