DELETE

TheGoonies1985

.

TheGoonies1985

Anyone?

Jzyskowski1

Is the coin moving? Is the case cracked? Could you please describe the noise better? Thanks 🤓🙀

MsMorrisine

Tilted which way?

Does it require 1 movement or back and forth?

TheGoonies1985

@Jzyskowski1 said:
Is the coin moving? Is the case cracked? Could you please describe the noise better? Thanks 🤓🙀

Nothing I see wrong just when you you tilt it it make a slight sound left or right.

TheGoonies1985

@MsMorrisine said:
Tilted which way?

Does it require 1 movement or back and forth?

I am not sure how to explain it just rotating the case in my hands at 180 degrees on either flat thiner side it makes that sound.

TheGoonies1985

The coin does not move maybe they make the inner white part some times just a tad to small and the clear part always the exact same size. Maybe the white part is not 100% solid in the inside and moves a tiny bit.

MsMorrisine

If you can’t see that the white inner holder is too small, I would ask if you need to vigorously move it or simply turn it?

I’ve never heard of this problem with NGC holders before.

What’s the coin?

TheGoonies1985

@MsMorrisine said:
If you can’t see that the white inner holder is too small, I would ask if you need to vigorously move it or simply turn it?

I’ve never heard of this problem with NGC holders before.

What’s the coin?

No need to turn it hard it is like I said seems like the inner white holder is just a tad to bit small. The coin does not move at all and the case is like new. It is a 10 cent pieces.

TheGoonies1985

It is not a huge deal was just curious it is a 650$ coin not a 6000$ coin.

MsMorrisine

Small coin, too. That deepens the mystery.

Wonder if something is inside

TheGoonies1985

@MsMorrisine said:
Small coin, too. That deepens the mystery.

Wonder if something is inside

I have a few NGC holders that do the same exact thing so I guess it can't be that rare.

ChrisH821

I have one that does it, like the insert moves inside the clamshell.

TheMayor

I have a few that make that sound as well. Needless to say, it is not comforting.

TheGoonies1985

@ChrisH821 said:
I have one that does it, like the insert moves inside the clamshell.

Yes just so very slightly.

TheGoonies1985

@TheMayor said:
I have a few that make that sound as well. Needless to say, it is not comforting.

What makes you worried mine I doubt anything will happen the cases are i perfect shape and the coins held tightly in place.

Maybe some here can contact NGC and let them know.

TheMayor

@KingOfMorganDollar said:

@TheMayor said:
I have a few that make that sound as well. Needless to say, it is not comforting.

What makes you worried mine I doubt anything will happen the cases are i perfect shape and the coins held tightly in place.

Maybe some here can contact NGC and let them know.

I wouldn't say I am worried but to me it indicates something about the product is slightly imprecise. I can't imagine they designed it to rattle around. Given the choice, I would rather not hear the sound at all, but like you, the coins I have in these holders are not particularly valuable and I am fine leaving them as is.

PerryHall

If this bothers you, don't buy a heavy coin such as a Morgan Dollar in a first generation PCGS "rattler" slab.