Picked up a Vintage Collection...Help with Potential Grades

AshleyBrown · April 30, 2021 7:19AM

I bought a Vintage Collection (about 300 Cards) recently. Now that grading is more expensive & more importantly takes a lengthy time to get cards back (I know PSA will not be taking in cards until July)...you have to be a little more selective in what you send in so...

What do you think these would grade?

I respect the knowledge on this forum & have no expectation of a particular grade, just wondering what some you guys think.

Rofles · April 30, 2021 9:21AM

Clemente and Aaron: PSA 5ish
Ernie banks RC: PSA 2-3
Willie Mays: PSA 4-5.5
Frank Robinson: PSA 4-5
IMHO.

handyman · April 30, 2021 9:36AM

4
5
2 MK
3
3

blurryface · April 30, 2021 9:37AM

those 57s are very white. got a pic of the backs?

nam812 · April 30, 2021 9:43AM

1957 Clemente 6
1957 Aaron 5
1954 Banks 3
1957 Mays 4
1957 Robinson 4

AshleyBrown · April 30, 2021 10:16AM

I was thinking...
Banks: 1
Clemente: 4-5
Aaron: 4-5
Mays: 3-4
Robinson 3-4

So I would be thrilled to get in the range you guys are saying. Thanks for the opinions

Pics of back coming shortly. These came from the original owner who purchased those as a kid. About 225 are 1957's and 175 or so are commons, they are 100% authentic.

nam812 · April 30, 2021 11:18AM

I'm gonna change my Clemente 6 to a 5, and if that's a crease in the upper left corner on Mays I will change that to a 3.

You have them in hand so you obviously can see things we cant, but these aren't beaters by any means.

AshleyBrown · April 30, 2021 11:21AM

@nam812 - Thanks. I was just letting you guys know I did not have high, or unrealistic, expectations. The Banks is a little rough, but the others are solid. I was deciding whether to grade or sell raw. I may keep one of the Clemente's (there were doubles of '57 Clemente, Banks, & Berra

Cakes · April 30, 2021 11:35AM

@blurryface said:
those 57s are very white. got a pic of the backs?

That was the first thing that caught my eye too.

Bosox1976 · April 30, 2021 12:08PM

4/4/1/4/3

handyman · April 30, 2021 1:46PM

Added MK to banks

4 Look ex but to OC
5 solid card
2 MK Added as I didnt see the mark on the bat. Maybe 1 MK bc of bottom boarder
3 Top left corner crease
3 bottom left corner crease In the C of Cinc