Clemente rookie

76collector

Hey all. I’m considering taking a shot at the following auction. But wondered if the crack in the case would scare you. The card itself seems a little weak for the grade but not really sketchy. And the seller has perfect feedback on over 20K transactions. So I don’t question the seller at all. Just a little hesitant to go after a card like this when there are any red flags. But it’s selling at a discount right now due to the case I believe.

Thanks in advance for your input.

Jeff

gemint

The crack in the case doesn't scare me but that does not look like a 4. Did they provide a back scan?

76collector

@gemint said:
The crack in the case doesn't scare me but that does not look like a 4. Did they provide a back scan?

Yes. Back is clean but corners look more like a 3 to me as well. And right now it’s selling at the price of a 3.

GreenSneakers

The saying is “buy the card not the holder”. But in this case, I’d pass on both.

Early_Milled_Latin_America

Same there is better out there in brand new PSA holders.

gemint

I agree. Unless they're selling it at a VG price point, I'd pass.

76collector

Thanks guys. That is exactly what I did as well. It crept up to well over 3K. When I was looking it was around 1700.