1874 PI MH 8 reales .....overdate ?

bidask

This close up from D&P

My actual coin which does not look like what is shown from D&P..... but then what is it ?

Abuelo

Looks more double stroke than overdate.

TwoKopeiki

Repunched digit. The die sinker didn't like the location by a few mm and repunched it slightly higher. Not an overdate or a double strike (where all elements would exhibit doubling)

PillarDollarCollector

4 over 4 repunched

Abuelo

@TwoKopeiki and @KingOfMorganDollar might be right.

PillarDollarCollector

The full date looks repunched look at it closer.

PillarDollarCollector

Bet you if you look all your coins over you will find something new or you did not know you had. You own 100's of 8 Reales there is a strong possibility of that. Ebay does not even have that many for sale from the period you collect. I know I would be looking each one over may take time but it would be time I enjoyed.

Give me some coffee and some relaxing music and I would be a happy camper.

bidask

Like this one ?

1860/9 c pv 8 reales from D&P.

!

This is what own . PCGS 63

What is under the 6 ?

PillarDollarCollector

Yes that 6 is very cool.

bidask

How about these two 67 c ce neither of which look like the pic for the overdate in
D&P ?? What are your thoughts ?

PillarDollarCollector

Seems they are like the original post you made. The 1860 is the best in my opinion.