1913 type 1 Buffalo

ike126

Does anyone know what the cdn bid is on a 1913 type 1 MS67??

LanceNewmanOCC

my sheets are a little old but they say $825. 13p 5c t1 ms67

Kliao

Currently it’s $550

Jimnight

$825.00 /$850.00

ike126

Thanks guy i see prices are all over the place for this one online etc

MFeld

@ike126 said:
Thanks guy i see prices are all over the place for this one online etc

That’s the case for a lot of coins. I’d figure an average selling price in the low to mid $500 range at auction, currently.

braddick

With immaculate luster and toning I'd think closer to 1K.

ike126

The tpg's are weird with the 66 and 67 grades with these i feel.

MFeld

@braddick said:
With immaculate luster and toning I'd think closer to 1K.

See here: https://www.ebay.com/itm/1913-P-PCGS-Secure-MS67-Type-1-Mound-Buffalo-Indian-Head-Nickel-GEM-BU-Colorful/153967688673?hash=item23d9307be1:g:ZVIAAOSwasBe4bfi

And this one sold for $552:
https://coins.ha.com/itm/buffalo-nickels/nickels/1913-5c-type-one-ms67-pcgs-pcgs-population-692-28-ngc-census-324-26-cdn-550-whsle-bid-for-ngc-pcgs-ms67-mintag/a/132023-21130.s?ic4=ListView-ShortDescription-071515

crazyhounddog

@MFeld said:

@braddick said:
With immaculate luster and toning I'd think closer to 1K.

See here: https://www.ebay.com/itm/1913-P-PCGS-Secure-MS67-Type-1-Mound-Buffalo-Indian-Head-Nickel-GEM-BU-Colorful/153967688673?hash=item23d9307be1:g:ZVIAAOSwasBe4bfi

All due respect.
Not very well struck shown on the buffalos head. Not a very attractive piece and not CAC’ed. Still it’s quite a shot from 500 bucks. I’ve seen 66-66+ sell in the 500 dollar range and higher but never a PCGS 67. I’ll be a buyer if I see one that’s worthy of the 67 grade assigned at the price.

MFeld

@crazyhounddog said:

@MFeld said:

@braddick said:
With immaculate luster and toning I'd think closer to 1K.

See here: https://www.ebay.com/itm/1913-P-PCGS-Secure-MS67-Type-1-Mound-Buffalo-Indian-Head-Nickel-GEM-BU-Colorful/153967688673?hash=item23d9307be1:g:ZVIAAOSwasBe4bfi

All due respect.
Not very well struck shown on the buffalos head. Not a very attractive piece and not CAC’ed. Still it’s quite a shot from 500 bucks. I’ve seen 66-66+ sell in the 500 dollar range and higher but never a PCGS 67. I’ll be a buyer if I see one that’s worthy of the 67 grade assigned.

I didn't say that CAC examples were obtainable in the low to mid $500 range.That example is also more of a "shot" from $1000 than it is from the figures I mentioned and that's an ask price. Did you look at the other link I provided?

While you might never have seen a PCGS 67 sell in the range I stated, I'm aware of at least half a dozen sales below $600 this year. A couple of them were below $500.

Even a few PCGS/CAC 67+ examples have brought in the low $1100 range and one brought $900. My research is done - your turn.

ChrisH821

There's less drama in the MS65 range.
They look almost as nice and cost less than half as much.

Here is the auction history page:
https://www.pcgs.com/auctionprices/details/1913-type-1-ms/3915
Average auction price for MS67(no plus, cac and non-cac, NGC and PCGS) this year so far is $611
There are outliers in both directions

Average for 67+ in the same time period is $1144

crazyhounddog

@MFeld said:

@crazyhounddog said:

@MFeld said:

@braddick said:
With immaculate luster and toning I'd think closer to 1K.

See here: https://www.ebay.com/itm/1913-P-PCGS-Secure-MS67-Type-1-Mound-Buffalo-Indian-Head-Nickel-GEM-BU-Colorful/153967688673?hash=item23d9307be1:g:ZVIAAOSwasBe4bfi

All due respect.
Not very well struck shown on the buffalos head. Not a very attractive piece and not CAC’ed. Still it’s quite a shot from 500 bucks. I’ve seen 66-66+ sell in the 500 dollar range and higher but never a PCGS 67. I’ll be a buyer if I see one that’s worthy of the 67 grade assigned.

I didn't say that CAC examples were obtainable in the low to mid $500 range.That example is also more of a "shot" from $1000 than it is from the figures I mentioned and that's an ask price. Did you look at the other link I provided?

While you might never have seen a PCGS 67 sell in the range I stated, I'm aware of at least half a dozen sales below $600 this year. A couple of them were below $500.

Even a few PCGS/CAC 67+ examples have brought in the low $1100 range and one brought $900. My research is done - your turn.

I don’t want to take my turn.

braddick

Granted, my 1K price would be for the immaculate top 5% within the grade- a simply outstanding single example- is high. Although that doesn't stop some from asking even more:
https://www.ebay.com/itm/1913-Buffalo-Nickel-Type-1-PCGS-MS67/293593406393?hash=item445b87dbb9:g:VgYAAOSwnlRevWFg:sc:USPSPriority!92069!US!-1

MFeld

@braddick said:
Granted, my 1K price would be for the immaculate top 5% within the grade- a simply outstanding single example- is high. Although that doesn't stop some from asking even more:
https://www.ebay.com/itm/1913-Buffalo-Nickel-Type-1-PCGS-MS67/293593406393?hash=item445b87dbb9:g:VgYAAOSwnlRevWFg:sc:USPSPriority!92069!US!-1

Granted, there’s probably always someone willing to ask more.😉