4/3 Over/properly/underpriced:1990 Score Emmitt Smith PSA 10 @ $340

1957Braves

Bring it back down to earth for the rest of us that can’t afford the Jordan. Here’s an example of a rookie of a superstar in a limited set in top grade. What say you?

Standard disclaimer:

Classifications

Overpriced-given the player, set, condition, etc. this card is currently selling for higher than you would expect. You would sell at the current price.

Properly priced- same thing, with your feeling that you would buy or sell a this price and feel comfortable.

Under priced- again same and you would buy at the current price.

To keep the discussion light and not getting bogged down by definitions, just think of the stated PSA standards of each grade, not a specific card for sale or recently sold. I’m also not looking at pop reports.

I don’t have VCP access, so I’ll just list the card and the average of the last two eBay sales.

Feel free to send me a PM if you want a particular card thrown out for discussion

lwehlers

Underpriced

I am a big emmitt smith fan being a cowboys fan I am. he is the all-time rusher and his rookie is limited since it came in a box set. just my opinion.

sayheywyo

Underpriced

Slightly underpriced. Football cards in general don't get near the respect they deserve. Not a big Emmitt fan but he is the all-time leading rusher. IMO running backs usually don't present much upside in value.

remedylane

Underpriced

Underpriced. I'm a cowboy fan, but promise I'm not being biased. All time leading rusher, pretty limited set, and those full color borders aren't an easy 10.