1936 Goudey Set Weighting

LuxuryWines

I am very close to getting the 1936 (Black & White R322) set listed on the registry.... I would like to have this set weighted here is my thoughts on the set .... I would suggest a 5 point scale due to the small size of the set .....

1 Walter Berger 1.0
2 Henry Bonura 1.5
3 Stan Bordagaray 1.0
4 Bill Brubaker 1.0
5 Dolph Camili 1.0
6 Clyde Castleman 1.0
7 Mickey Cochrane 4.0
8 Joe Coscart 1.0
9 Frank Crosetti 2.0
10 Kiki Cuyler 3.0
11 PAul Derringer 1.0
12 Jimmy Dykes 1.0
13 Rick Ferrel 2.5
14 Lefty Gomez 4.0
15 Hank Greenburg 5.0
16 Bucky Harris 2.5
17 Rollie Hemsley 1.0
18 Frank Higgins 1.0
19 Orel Hildebrand 1.0
20 Chuck Klein 3.0
21 Pepper Martin 2.0
22 Buck Newsom 1.0
23 Joe Vosmik 1.0
24 Paul Waner 3.5
25 Bill Weber 1.0

Any thoughts or suggestions ??? Jeff

vorthian

<< Any thoughts or suggestions ??? >>

While it is a small set, I'd suggest using the 10 point scale. Much more accurate, imho.

zardoz51

I agree with Vorthian,

Greenburg, Gomez, and Cochrane need to stand out from the commons by a far wider margin.

LuxuryWines

OKay How does this Look? 10 Point scale .. I left all the commons as a 1 and doubled the Star/HOF cards...

1 Walter Berger 1.0
2 Henry Bonura 2.0
3 Stan Bordagaray 1.0
4 Bill Brubaker 1.0
5 Dolph Camili 1.0
6 Clyde Castleman 1.0
7 Mickey Cochrane 8.0
8 Joe Coscart 1.0
9 Frank Crosetti 4.0
10 Kiki Cuyler 6.0
11 PAul Derringer 1.0
12 Jimmy Dykes 1.0
13 Rick Ferrel 5.0
14 Lefty Gomez 8.0
15 Hank Greenburg 10.0
16 Bucky Harris 5.0
17 Rollie Hemsley 1.0
18 Frank Higgins 1.0
19 Orel Hildebrand 1.0
20 Chuck Klein 6.0
21 Pepper Martin 4.0
22 Buck Newsom 1.0
23 Joe Vosmik 1.0
24 Paul Waner 7.0
25 Bill Weber 1.0