Retiring my #11 HOF Player set: many HOFer cards FS here

paleocards

I’m retiring my HOF Players set, currently ranked #11 (out of 483 registered sets) and one of only six that is 100% complete. To be clear, I’m not selling every card but I’m offering a number of relatively obscure, some tough to find, second-tier HOFers from 1950 Callahan Hall of Fame (12), 1960 (30) & 1961 (24 including 5 high-#’s) Fleer All-Time Greats, 1972 Laughlin Great Feats (2), 1976 Shakey’s Pizza Hall of Fame (16) and 1994 American Archives Origins of Baseball (5). For anyone working on PSA unrestricted HOF sets (“Players,” “Complete” etc.) adding these cards can give you a significant boost to your rankings.

All of the Callahans and Fleers are in PSA 8, the Shakey’s average 8.03 and 7 of the 8 of the Laughlins and American Archives are in PSA 9. You can see scans of each card in the sets linked below or in my HOF Players set.

I’d prefer to sell them all in one lot for $1150 (includes USPS Priority boxed & insured shipping) but my pricing below reflects what I’ll take for smaller groupings.

1950 Callahan Hall of Fame, all PSA 8, 12 cards*
Pick 5, $22 each (includes shipping)
Pick 10, $20 each (includes shipping)
All 12 for $216 (=$18 each, includes shipping)
* Candy Cummings & George Wright are NOT for sale

1960 Fleer All-Time Greats, all PSA 8, 30 cards
Pick 5, $22 each (includes shipping)
Pick 10, $18 each (includes shipping)
All 30 for $450 (=$15 each, includes shipping)

1961 Fleer All-Time Greats, all PSA 8, 24 cards*
Pick 5 low-#’s, $15 each (includes shipping)
All 5 high-#’s (card numbers >=100), $20 each (includes shipping)
Pick 10 low #’s, $12.50 each (includes shipping)
Pick 10, combo of low & high-#’s, $17.50 each (includes shipping)
All 24 for $300 (=$12.50 each, includes shipping)
* Wes Ferrell, NOT a HOFer, is included among the low-#’s

1972 Laughlin Great Feats (Blue Border), 2 cards
#10 Ed Delahanty PSA 9, $10
#40 Joe Sewell PSA 9, $8

1976 Shakey’s Pizza Hall of Fame, 16 cards (8.03 GPA: 2 PSA 7, 10 PSA 8, 3 PSA 8.5, 1 PSA 9)
Pick 5, $22 each (includes shipping)
Pick 10, $20 each (includes shipping)
All 16 for $280 (=$17.50 each, includes shipping)

1994 American Archives Origins of Baseball, 5 cards
#28 Bid McPhee PSA 9, $20
#33 Roger Conner PSA 9, $20
#57 Tim Keefe PSA 9, $20
#68 Amos Rusie PSA 8, $15
#69 Jake Beckley PSA 9, $20

By the way, I’ve consigned my complete 33 card, PSA-graded 1961 Golden Press set (it was part of my HOF Players set) with PWCC as a single-lot to be sold in their Premium Auction #4 (starting at the end of March). It has an 8.37 weighted GPA and an 8.55 unweighted GPA and is currently ranked #38 on the registry. This set includes all of the big pre-war HOFers including Ruth, Cobb, DiMaggio, Gehrig, Wagner, Young and others.