Blown TPG Call - 1858/9 Shilling

7Jaguars · July 25, 2018 5:41AM

I apologies for the poor photography off of my iPhone.

This coin submitted to "P" and designated by me on submission as an [obvious] overdate. They also graded it "53"! Yikes, I know poor photography and my coin but really that is ridiculous. Admittedly better in hand ATS they designated it correctly and graded it "58".

7Jaguars · July 25, 2018 5:43AM

In other words, P designated it as no overdate even though submitted as such...

brg5658 · July 25, 2018 7:31AM

Not clear where it now resides -- "P" or "N" -- BUT if you went from "N" --> "P" this would beg the question, why the hell would someone waste your money to send it to "P" in the first place? Then complain when "P" doesn't put it in plastic saying the exact thing that "N" had already declared?

Bizarre...

7Jaguars · July 25, 2018 2:34PM

No, not bizarre. P is where it went first and where they missed the call entirely in both grade and designation. I respect them and have many coins in P holders. I wanted it slabbed, and correctly so and voila to N it went.

Blown TPG Call - 1858/9 Shilling

Comments