Search
-
Pricing a coin - part 2 (prices revealed)
Let's try this a slightly different way. For the below coin, please let us know the following: 1) What price do you personally place on this coin? 2) What price would you expect it to sell at? I have several photos of the coin from different photographers. Note that the cert number has been hidden in order to avoid any… -
Re: Pricing a coin - part 2 (prices revealed)
1) Nice looking coin. I would expect at least 20% over guide. 2) Put it up at auction. I would hope for 50% over guide. -
Re: Pricing a coin - part 2 (prices revealed)
Reveal: This sold this past Sunday for a hint over $3k at GC with the buyer’s fee...same coin sold for 1,200 at HA just last year and 2,115 at Legend in 2016. So quite the spread over the years and venues! I didn’t love the coin based on my interpretation of the photos and considered its price to be closer to the HA result… -
Re: Pricing a coin - part 2 (prices revealed)
My price: $250-$400 What I expect: $1250-$2000 *Just a little added bit of info: I saw a late date Walker (1945) that was graded NGC MS 64 * for $5000 on a dealers website. I have a very comparable date Coin that looks much nicer (1945-D) in NGC MS 66 * and mine has a CAC sticker that the dealer’s coin lacks. I think I… -
Re: Pricing a coin - part 2 (prices revealed)
I would pay $500. But I would expect it to sell for $2000. -
Re: Pricing a coin - part 2 (prices revealed)
I’ve always been cheap when it comes to toned coins, everything I have, I got for the normal coin price, with the exception of paying slightly over for my reverse crescent toner from 1886, I believe Gray sheet was around 140? I offered 200 and got it… I will admit I would pay up on that one probably nothing like some… -
Re: Pricing a coin - part 2 (prices revealed)
I think the coin is a little dark to get the huge money for it. That said, if I were a buyer I would pay $750 and I would hope to eventually sell it for $1,250. But of course your mileage may vary. -
Re: Pricing a coin - part 2 (prices revealed)
I remember one of these selling north of $5K on GC. -
Re: Pricing a coin - part 2 (prices revealed)
The right holder, pictures, and auction; these have gone crazy on GC. -
Re: Pricing a coin - part 2 (prices revealed)
Well that was one of the venues and one of the pictures in the original post. I’d call the GC result crazy indeed.
15 results