Search
-
Re: GB Victorian followed by Edward VII and George III Coinage// 1871 1/2d added 2/9
The 1871 1/2 d is a tougher date in MS- misses RB, but still within my estimated grade range. -
Re: GB Victorian followed by Edward VII and George III Coinage// 1871 1/2d added 2/9
The image of the 1902 shilling is unusual- The coin does not have what almost looks like an s behind and below the eye of Edward VII. It does look better in hand- My range was 64 shot 65. I think the highest grade I have obtained on an Edward VII shilling is 64, but then again, I have submitted very few- perhaps 4-5. Still… -
Re: GB Victorian followed by Edward VII and George III Coinage// 1871 1/2d added 2/9
I have submitted a ton of Edward VII Shillings. Ended up with a ton of MS64s haha. Gem is soooo incredibly difficult and honestly, I think even tougher for 1902. -
Re: GB Victorian followed by Edward VII and George III Coinage// 1871 1/2d added 2/9
I think that the hosts were a bit harsh, especially on the 3 shillings and the 1902 shilling. The images are nice but not nearly as nice as they used to. They did capture the peripheral subtle toning of the 3s. Wow, what a lovely, well-matched group! 💕 I'll second that. -
Re: GB Victorian followed by Edward VII and George III Coinage// 1871 1/2d added 2/9
For the curious... the PCGS grades are as follows: 1850 3d - MS63 1838 Sh- AU55 1889 DF - MS62 1902 Sh - MS63 1812 3S - AU58 -
Re: GB Victorian followed by Edward VII and George III Coinage// 1871 1/2d added 2/9
The 1812 bank token is a 55/58 in my opinion. I would think that it made your expectations. -
GB Victorian followed by Edward VII and George III Coinage// 1871 1/2d added 2/9
1889 Double Florin- Nice look but missed expectations- nice image 1838 Shilling is decent but just not an MS coin- nice image 1850 3 Pence- nice coin and missed expectations The 1902 Shilling is quite common- I thought this was better than most but missed a GEM grade . This was one of the gambles in the submission- Tell me… -
Re: GB Victorian followed by Edward VII and George III Coinage// 1871 1/2d added 2/9
Wow, what a lovely, well-matched group! 💕 -
Re: GB Victorian followed by Edward VII and George III Coinage// 1871 1/2d added 2/9
@Johnnyb Thanks for the comments. My reasons for sharing grade results primarily is to just illustrate what is possible and that grading in general has a subjective component. Coins graded at a certain level are not equal- some will look better than others. -
Re: GB Victorian followed by Edward VII and George III Coinage// 1871 1/2d added 2/9
These coins all look original and great, and generally under-graded by a grade. They have great eye appeal.
13 results