Search

1. GTG - $2-1/2 Indian 63+ CAC holder. Should I send it in for 64 reconsideration and lose the sticker?

   

   

   Discussion by Goldminers · May 21, 2023 5:01AM · Home› U.S. Coin Forum

   Edited to ask, do you think the new CAC would call it a 64 if it was sent there?

2. Re: GTG - $2-1/2 Indian 63+ CAC holder. Should I send it in for 64 reconsideration and lose the sticker?

   

   Comment by Cougar1978 · May 21, 2023 7:23AM · Home› U.S. Coin Forum

   A bump up to 64 from 63 plus would add $5000 in MV per Coin Facts. $17500 to $22500. In addition the number graded higher would shrink by 333. Then in MS 64 only 34 graded higher. Upgrade to 64 a super double play. I would send it in to our hosts specifying minimum grade of MS64. If it upgrades, I guess that’s where me and…

3. Re: GTG - $2-1/2 Indian 63+ CAC holder. Should I send it in for 64 reconsideration and lose the sticker?

   

   Comment by HillbillyCollector · May 21, 2023 6:51PM · Home› U.S. Coin Forum

   If it were mine, I would probably be happy as is. Otherwise, try for a reconsideration but if you get it, I’m not certain about stickering, if this is a deal breaker. Good luck! Oh, edit to add that I do love the coin!

4. Re: GTG - $2-1/2 Indian 63+ CAC holder. Should I send it in for 64 reconsideration and lose the sticker?

   

   Comment by Goldminers · May 21, 2023 7:22AM · Home› U.S. Coin Forum

   Thanks, I have the rest of the entire set in 64 to 65+ all CAC except this 63+ key. It looks like a higher grade to me compared to several others in my set, but I may be biased ;) . I would really like to see this in a 64 CAC holder if it is justified, but I am not a CAC member so I may have to wait a while to understand…

5. Re: GTG - $2-1/2 Indian 63+ CAC holder. Should I send it in for 64 reconsideration and lose the sticker?

   

   Comment by Smudge · May 21, 2023 5:47AM · Home› U.S. Coin Forum

   Looks 64. Nice look to that one.

6. Re: GTG - $2-1/2 Indian 63+ CAC holder. Should I send it in for 64 reconsideration and lose the sticker?

   

   Comment by Goldminers · May 22, 2023 4:10AM · Home› U.S. Coin Forum

   @Cougar1978, Thanks for the advice. Now I am staying up at night waiting for CACG to open. LOL

7. Re: GTG - $2-1/2 Indian 63+ CAC holder. Should I send it in for 64 reconsideration and lose the sticker?

   

   Comment by BillJones · May 22, 2023 3:27AM · Home› U.S. Coin Forum

   Which is more valuable, an MS-63+ with a CAC sticker or an MS-64 without it? Given the imperial status that many collectors give to the sticker, the MS-63 is probably the better bet. Of course, the MS-64 with the sticker would be better, but what is the marginal cost and reward for doing that? Given the high costs for…

8. Re: GTG - $2-1/2 Indian 63+ CAC holder. Should I send it in for 64 reconsideration and lose the sticker?

   

   Comment by PerryHall · May 22, 2023 1:27AM · Home› U.S. Coin Forum

   Agree and I had the same thought. If you don't try for a MS64, it will eventually drive you insane. :o

9. Re: GTG - $2-1/2 Indian 63+ CAC holder. Should I send it in for 64 reconsideration and lose the sticker?

   

   Comment by Coinscratch · May 21, 2023 5:23PM · Home› U.S. Coin Forum

   I would. Nothing to lose and everything to gain. Nice looking piece.

10. Re: GTG - $2-1/2 Indian 63+ CAC holder. Should I send it in for 64 reconsideration and lose the sticker?

    

    Comment by Goldminers · May 21, 2023 3:08PM · Home› U.S. Coin Forum

    Thank you for your discussion. This is exactly what I have been thinking about as well. The upgrade value is significant, and these Indians have been getting very strong bids lately. Part of the reason I have not been able to improve my set much recently, as I keep getting outbid a bit beyond my financial capability. I…