dallasactuary ✭✭✭✭✭

With fielding there is never "proof", there is only evidence. Part of the comparison is that RF in Yankee Stadium was pretty small and RF (and CF) in Oakland Coliseum were enormous. Ruth wa… (View Post)

There are no doubt people with many fewer plate appearances who were even better than Reggie, but Dykstra and Gibson weren't in the conversation when Reggie was crowned Mr. October. And obviousl… (View Post)

Regular season sure. But Reggie got an extra base hit almost twice as often in the World Series. So your argument comes down to this: Killebrew was a great hitter ===> Reggie was nearly twice as g… (View Post)

That "feels" about right. Win Shares uses a very similar "runs saved" formula in it's calculations, so I thought I'd check this list against that list. By Win Shares, th… (View Post)

I don't think you can get inducted into the HOF twice, so Torre will have to make do with his manager election. But yes, he was definitely screwed when he didn't get in as a player. That wa… (View Post)