cameonut2011 ✭✭✭✭✭
Reactions
-
Re: Started looking at W.L. Halves lately and saw this MS64 CAC approved 1921 in a GC auction.
It’s not a coin I’d be super excited to buy. The toning is a negative. My first thought was perhaps it was netgraded, but I struggle to see this coin as a gem without the toning. The toning should ha… (View Post)1 -
Re: Update… Coin returned!
It looks like this thread had a happy ending. The coin will be returned. In light of the response posted by the dealer, I don’t see any reputational harm. (View Post)4 -
Re: A True Test To See If CACG Is As Strict As Perceived
No. A submitter is paying for their honest opinion, and CACG is giving the submitter just that. That the submitter doesn’t like the result doesn’t change that. (View Post)2 -
Re: A True Test To See If CACG Is As Strict As Perceived
Your entire argument assumes there is only one true grade or even true grading scale. Grading is subjective and there is no one true/controlling set of standards. Look at PCGS and NGC. While based on… (View Post)2 -
Re: A True Test To See If CACG Is As Strict As Perceived
This sounds like financial suicide. There is a lot of risk and downside but no upside. And if you are to submit 500 widgets, that does not necessarily reflect the larger market. All TPGs are stricter… (View Post)3